Sorry, just wake up. #TimezoneProbs As Yvess said, both the Redemption entries were really close and perfect for the theme so I made a difference on a little thing just cause I couldn't give two 10s but anyone who will win will deserve it.
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
I've had my wake up wont Mario WAKE UP
I keep asking why
Stupid italian
Spaghetti stallion
What happened? He passed by.
I resist the urge to kick you just cause you probably find that exciting, disgusting pervert!
Hello, Guero & wesleywalrus to the 8th & Final Redemption Island Duel. Last duel, Guero came out victorious for a second time eliminating Bey_RihStan in the process. Now is the time one of you re-joins the game, and the other is officially sent packing.
Let's see what you both brought to the table this duel...
The Entries:
1. Guero - Evanescence - My Immortal
Quote:
Dylan - 9.5 - Both very strong entries for the round. Yours is weaker lyrically but luckily Amy's vocal delivery is beautifully emotional and the band arrangement is so haunting. That emotion pulled you the win for at least my ratings. Shame to see either leave when both entries are truly great for the round.
Quote:
Ethan - 10 - While this isn't a relationship I envy, the person they lost (I think it's the writer's grandpa? Or uncle? Something.) was clearly very important to them. This song has so much emotion in it and I love it in all of it's versions.
Quote:
Yvess - 10 - I love this song. I will always cry to this song. The piano, amy lee's vocal prowess and the haunting lyrics gets me everytime. You get a perfect 10 from me because this is much sad of a song compared to the other track. You have performed very well on Survivor and it's really sad to see anyone of you miss the merge.
Quote:
Mario - 9.5 - Perfectly fitting to the theme. The singer sure loved with all her heart the person that's gone. I would've given you both 10s in a normal challenge but here I had to make a difference and that was created by the detail I explained to Wesley.
2. wesleywalrus - Mariah Carey feat. Boys II Men - One Sweet Day
Quote:
Dylan - 9 - Both of you brought your best to this round which i love. Lyrically, this is stronger as it's more direct. The only flaw to this entry is that sonically it isn't as emotional due to the standard R&B production that doesn't come off quite as emotional as the chilling My Immortal production. Sad to see either of you go with entries like these.
Quote:
Ethan - 9 - The lyrics to this song are really strong, they fit perfectly, but the production is very cheap R&B and I feel like Mariah's delivery is more about showing off her voice than really conveying a real emotion. Still a stellar choice!
Quote:
Yvess - 9.5 - Oh my gosh. THIS IS ALSO HEARTBREAKING. The lyrics and the emotions from Mooriah is very heartfelt. It's hard to see anyone of you go this time.
Quote:
Mario - 10 - If it was about the better song, I would've picked My Immortal with no hesitation at all. Concerning this theme, though, One Sweet Day suits the challenge even better just for the fact that here it's made more explicit that it's about someone who's dead and a little less hinted.
Click the collapse to reveal the winner of Duel #8!
Winner
Guero - 9.8
You've won your third duel of the season, Guero! Not only does that break a record for this season but it means you are the official comeback contestant of the season. You are officially a part of the Top 13 and may now claim an artist and complete Round 11. Congratulations and a job well done!
Eliminated:
14. wesleywalrus - 9.4
wesleywalrus - Though you put up a good fight, your Survivor journey ends tonight. You gave your all this round and received a great score for the round. However, Guero brought his best as well and nabbed the win by doing so. You've played well this season all things considered. You've had good scores but have also played a social game when your fate depended upon it. Thank you for signing up for my game as I appreciate all the new faces I can get on this island. Hope you enjoyed your stay while it lasted.
Continue working on your entries guys. A new Hidden Immunity Idol will be coming into play soon.
Winner
