[8thPrince]

Considering if I want to get my teeth filed ALL the way down when I get my braces taken off. I have VICIOUS canines and I think canine-smiles are cute.

[minho]

I was actually kind of curious, how would you be judging this round? Is it the quality of the song itself or how well it fits the chosen album?

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by lovesong

I was actually kind of curious, how would you be judging this round? Is it the quality of the song itself or how well it fits the chosen album?

Each judge has a different system I suppose. When it comes to my method, everytime there's a task (excluding round 1, free zone etc), it's usually 70% quality and 30% relevance to the task. So, if your song is perfect but has nothing to do with your album, you'll get a 7. If your song sucks, but it's thematically perfect for your album, you'll be able to at least snatch a 3.

[conatus]

Fefe and Matty (?) don't really know my album.

[minho]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Each judge has a different system I suppose. When it comes to my method, everytime there's a task (excluding round 1, free zone etc), it's usually 70% quality and 30% relevance to the task. So, if your song is perfect but has nothing to do with your album, you'll get a 7. If your song sucks, but it's thematically perfect for your album, you'll be able to at least snatch a 3.

oh that makes sense, thanks!

Though because I feel like my song's structure might affect my score but at least I have the relevance portion.

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by conatus

Fefe and Matty (?) don't really know my album.

Their loss

[minho]

Originally posted by conatus

Fefe and Matty (?) don't really know my album.

Your album literally slays.

I know most people say Funeral is their best but The Suburbs is such a classic. One of my fave albums ever, and for the longest time my favourite band too.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Their loss

True.

Do you personally know all the albums well enough? (Genuinely curious!)

[conatus]

Originally posted by lovesong

Your album literally slays.

I know most people say Funeral is their best but The Suburbs is such a classic. One of my fave albums ever, and for the longest time my favourite band too.

Funeral has always been their least-favourite for me! Neon Bible is where it's at.

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by conatus

True.

Do you personally know all the albums well enough? (Genuinely curious!)

I know each and every album extremely well minus Alanis' album which I personally hate and only listened to once in my life because apparently it's a classic so I felt obligated to

[conatus]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

I know each and every album extremely well minus Alanis' album which I personally hate and only listened to once in my life because apparently it's a classic so I felt obligated to

But Jagged Little Pill is great!

I low-key have always preferred Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie, though.

[minho]

Originally posted by conatus

Funeral has always been their least-favourite for me! Neon Bible is where it's at.

The Suburbs > Funeral = Neon Bible > Reflektor

I like all though.

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by conatus

But Jagged Little Pill is great!

I low-key have always preferred Supposed Former Infatuation Junkie, though.

Her voice irks me and her melodies never catch on. I only like Thank You and You Oughta Know

[conatus]

Originally posted by lovesong

The Suburbs > Funeral = Neon Bible > Reflektor

I like all though.

Neon Bible > The Suburbs > Reflektor > Funeral, with TS and Reflektor being interchangeable. All are great, though.

Ugh, such a perfect band.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Her voice irks me and her melodies never catch on.

Sis, you're setting yourself up here.

[minho]

I don't like Alanis very much either

Her JLP songs are still played as recurrent here though.

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by conatus

Sis, you're setting yourself up here.

My fave had more than 1 hit album, so long heeeerr don't ceeerrr

[keshaspearsxo]

Nudity

[minho]

I'm surprised there were no Janet albums up for option. A Velvet Rope or s/t inspired song could be really interesting.

[conatus]

Originally posted by lovesong

I'm surprised there were no Janet albums up for option. A Velvet Rope or s/t inspired song could be really interesting.

I definitely would have picked TVR over The Suburbs.

Rhythm Nation would have fit into the challenge, in my opinion.