[Daydream]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

I didn't give it a 10 or a 9

You must have given it your 11 then. That's the only possible reason.

[Truth Teller]

1. First song eliminated : Irresistible
2. First album eliminated : Charmbracelet
3. First #1 eliminated: Thank God I Found You
4. Highest rated song from Charmbracelet: Yours
5. Winning song: The Roof

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by Daydream

You must have given it your 11 then. That's the only possible reason.

Wrong

[Daydream]

I will be asleep through the opening tonight but I will catch up tomorrow.

So in advance, bye bye "Auld Lang Syne", "Me. I Am Mariah", "Don't Stop (Funkin' 4 Jamaica)" and "X-Girlfriend". It was good knowing you!

[sk8erfan]

Why do people hate X-Girlfriend so much?

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by sk8erfan

Why do people hate X-Girlfriend so much?

No idea. It's a bop

[STMG23]

I am really curious to know those first 8 songs because I know have rated songs lower than those some lambs are predicting to be dropped early.

For example, I like X-G, because even though it is kind of dated now it has really nice vocals in the verses (I like the lower register).

[Daydream]

I can maybe see "To The Floor" being eliminated this early on.

[Sissy]

Why are y'all hating on Me. I Am Mariah...The Elysian Chanson?

1. First song eliminated: To The Floor *crossing my fingers*
2. First album eliminated: Charmbracelet – It can't be any other way
3. First #1 eliminated: Thank God I Found You when it should be I Don't Wanna Cry
4. Highest rated song from Charmbracelet: The One – Why y'all think it could be BOTH?
5. Winning song: Always Be My Baby

[STMG23]

Originally posted by Daydream

I can maybe see "To The Floor" being eliminated this early on.

So do I. It's really the weakest song on a strong album. This makes it even weaker.

[minho]

I'd love To The Floor going early but I don't see a TEOM track leaving first.

Its definitely one of the worst though, but still there was one song I dragged from that album even more.

[Daydream]

Touch My Sexy Curvalicious Body is the best song EVER. It's out of this world.

[Theus]

Is just me but X-Girlfriend sounds like No Scrubs?

[Subomie]

1. First song eliminated: Irresistable
2. First album eliminated: Charmbracelet
3. First #1 eliminated: Thank God I Found You
4. Highest rated song from Charmbracelet: Bringin' on the Heartbreak
5. Winning song: Vision of Love

[Theus]

1. First song eliminated: Irresistable
2. First album eliminated: Charmbracelet
3. First #1 eliminated: Thank God I Found You
4. Highest rated song from Charmbracelet: Bringin' on the Heartbreak
5. Winning song: The Roof

[STMG23]

Lambilies, I will try to catch this event. But I hope we will get a breakdown on all the important stuff: first eliminated album, most successful album etc.

I can't guarantee I will be able to keep track but I am so hyped.

[minho]

Vision Of Love was my lowest of the '90s lead singles.

This rate made me realize that, although good, its not really amazing. Especially in the context of her entire discography.

[I Am Music]

To The Floor was the true definition of filler.

[STMG23]

I want to stress once again (in case some of my votes will be dragged) that I have really fallen in love with much of the early discography. "I Don't Wanna Cry" is my favorite from the first 3 albums right now and I could never have imagined until three weeks ago.

[Rated]

Originally posted by Daydream

So in advance, bye bye "Auld Lang Syne", "Me. I Am Mariah", "Don't Stop (Funkin' 4 Jamaica)" and "X-Girlfriend". It was good knowing you!

Why did this masterpiece deserve your revenge?