Circus is def a success if you do the Rihanna having 5 standard.
Commercially, I think Circus is bigger than AGLM, MOTS and RR
Overall size of the era is only part of the formula. The context is very important. ARTPOP sold the same as Bangerz but ARTPOP was a flop and Bangerz was a success.
But you know, I'm not stopping anyone from making their own list.
6/18/2011 – Lady Gaga – Born This Way – 84% – From 1.11 million to 174,000 at No. 1
12/7/2013 - Lady Gaga - ARTPOP - 82% - From 258,000 to 46,000 at No. 8
I don't need a parachute
Baby if I've got you, baby if I've got you
I don't need a parachute
You're gonna catch me
You're gonna catch if I fall
Down, down, down
I Wanna Be Your Lover
When You Were Mine
Uptown
Controversy
1999
Little Red Corvette
Erotic City
When Doves Cry
Let's Go Crazy
Purple Rain
The Beautiful Ones
I Would Die 4 U
Raspberry Beret
Pop Life
The Ladder
Kiss
I Wonder U
Under the Cherry Moon
Do U Lie?
Anotherloverholenyohead
Sometimes It Snows in April
Sign 'o' the Times
U Got the Look
Slow Love
Adore
It
Strange Relationship
The Cross
The Future
Electric Chair
I Wish U Heaven
Nothing Compares 2 U
Diamonds and Pearls
Cream
Thieves in the Temple
The Most Beautiful Girl in the World
I Hate U
P Control
Overall size of the era is only part of the formula. The context is very important. ARTPOP sold the same as Bangerz but ARTPOP was a flop and Bangerz was a success.
But you know, I'm not stopping anyone from making their own list.
So are you saying Shanias second era doesn't count as success only cuz it went diamond once as opposed to the previous era that went double diamond? I mean losing half the album sales is a huge decline
Tore his damn nose off
