Finished my judging. Here's my final-ish breakdown:
Six 10s
Four 9s
Six 8s
Seven 7s
Eleven 6s
Thirteen 5s
Three 4s
Five 3s
One 2
One 1
One 0
Overall Average: 6.103
Basically, 10 is really, really good, 5 is mediocre and anything 2 or below means I assumed you sent in your song as a joke (and you probably did).
My biggest critiques were to be more creative, to avoid overdone, trite ideas/phrases, to develop your own personal songwriting voice and that songs didn't make sense. Most people got at least one of these comments. You're going to notice these are critiques that will eternally come up in my comments because I really do not enjoy lyrics that are basic and uncreative.
Bitch I used to play trombone! I quit because people kept on telling me it sounded like I was farting every time I played it.