[collin]

Originally posted by QueenB

did you quote yourself and agree with it..?

No?

-

R8 is her riskiest era so far.

[bluth]

Originally posted by collin

BBHMM: a song with "bitch" in the title still going Top 20... and not first week

godney's impact!

and ffs IS a pop song with folk influences. she sings about looking forward to the weekend. not buying this risky business!

[collin]

Originally posted by bastille

Chubbi nooooooooooo
asdksdajsadjksdajksdaj Thanks collin for giving me a good laugh

She's so funny. You already knoooow!

[bluth]

Originally posted by Shinning

The Queen of Pop.
Poor poor Madead

serving in between eras as per!

[Giselle]

This era is more messy than it is risky.

[collin]

Originally posted by bluth

godney's impact!

and ffs IS a pop song with folk influences. she sings about looking forward to the weekend. not buying this risky business!

It's relatable but it's risky. She has never recorded anything like it and neither have any of the other pop girls sans Madonna - it is what it is.

[Starstruck.]

I don't see any excuses for TIHWD bombing

I only said it has more views than any Lad Gag music video this decade (or any video of hers except for 1)

Did any of Gag's flop singles achieve anything impressive?

[Golden]

TIHWD is Katy's best song. Should've been her third 6m+ seller tbh.

[Kworb]

Originally posted by Ramos

Stop making excuses.

The flawless TIHWD FLOPPED. Like BOMBED.

Originally posted by Kworb

Views last week

This Is How We Do 4,689,389

Applause 846,897
Telephone 667,205
Alejandro 591,768
Born This Way 547,808
Judas 484,913
G.U.Y. 359,790
G.U.Y. - An ARTPOP Film 286,295
Yoü And I 193,487
The Edge Of Glory 192,766
Do What U Want (Audio) 119,317
Marry The Night 113,677
Applause (Audio) 60,896
Venus (Audio) 53,117
Dope (Audio) 10,786
Applause (Lyric Video) 5,578
= 4,534,300

One "flop" song overshadowing Gaga her entire discography after Bad Romance

[Doogle]

It's so funny that pretty much everyone's faves are flopping now and this whole forum is just arguing about who flopped the least.. like what happens in a few years does everyone move on to arguing about Meghan vs Ariana or do they stay talking about the same things for the rest of their time on ATRL like we do in the Kesha base?

I wonder if ATRL was this unaccepting of new pop girls back when Gaga/Katy/Rih etc were all starting out? Or if it's just because Meghan really is that talentless and awful

Hopefully in her third era Ariana grows a personality and stage presence so she can really be the new queen

[Bounce]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

#1 Australia
#1 New Zealand
#1 Austria
#1 Denmark
#2 France
#2 Netherlands
#3 Canada
#3 Germany
#3 United Kingdom

How is this NOT a huge hit? Its having longevity worldwide unlike Applause that peaked high and bombed everywhere besides North America.

Birthday flopped in charts and views I'll give you that (even though we know why it has ****** streams!)

This Is How We Do flopped in charts but did amazing in streaming people actually know the song exists and streamed it, you can't erase those 400M streams from Spotify + VEVO! the views are on par with some smash hits from last year!

and hmm I guess G.U.Y., Judas and Marry The Night should've done better

I never I said It FLOPPED..? But it isn't huge either and the sales aren't great for a Rihanna lead single.

I also never said her streaming isn't great I just said it flopped on the charts which is more important than views.

Yep G.U.Y. and MTN flopped but Judas a PLATINUM TOP 10 VEVO WW hit and the fact that It wasn't friendly at all makes it more impressive

[collin]

Originally posted by Giselle

This era is more messy than it is risky.

Yeah, that's true.

What I'm trying to say is I'm proud of Rih using her power to do something new and not something generic and expected. It's still calculated but it's not LOUD 7.0 like everyone wanted. The other gyals be doing the most unexciting BS while Rih tests the waters and releases a string of polarizing songs.

[ezra]

Originally posted by Meowster

GaGa really delivered with Applause.

She did. No promo, too

[FreeBitch]

The fact that 7/11 feels bigger than any Rihanna singles this era.

[OurLuckyStrike]

Listening to R8 in its entirety will be a mess.

[bastille]

Chubbi ZZZ is serving (?)

[collin]

7/11 does not feel bigger than FFS. This = delusional and wrong.

[collin]

Originally posted by bastille

Chubbi ZZZ is serving (?)

Stop calling her Chubbi, she's not

[B-Luke]

Originally posted by Giselle

f; Yes, I'm sure she was WEEPING over her peaks in Germany

You know what she's more than likely doing this every night. Crying and ranting about it, drinking herself to sleep and tossing glasses at the wall.

[QueenB]

Originally posted by Doogle

It's so funny that pretty much everyone's faves are flopping now and this whole forum is just arguing about who flopped the least.. like what happens in a few years does everyone move on to arguing about Meghan vs Ariana or do they stay talking about the same things for the rest of their time on ATRL like we do in the Kesha base?

I wonder if ATRL was this unaccepting of new pop girls back when Gaga/Katy/Rih etc were all starting out? Or if it's just because Meghan really is that talentless and awful

Hopefully in her third era Ariana grows a personality and stage presence so she can really be the new queen

none of my faves have flopped recently so...?