[Nialler]

Marlene sis, hope you've already found youself some shelter.

[Sasha.]

i bet jason is A

[waryofothers]

Originally posted by OnlyManInTheWorld

It's not exactly the same and you should admit this theory could be right. There are no reasons to think it's fake.

Or maybe you have another explanation for the whole Radley- Bethany - Mrs. Cavanaugh - Mrs. D thing.

There's no such thing as a fake nor real theory. They're just theories.

And yes, there are holes in their theory.

• Uber A and Big A are the same person.
  Alison didn't even know Bethany.
  Alison didn't kill Mona.

And I've been posting about the Cece, Radley, Bethany, Marion, and Mrs. DiLaurentis connection ever since, like, January. Lol. CeCe was visiting Radley pretending to be Alison and that's where she befriended Bethany. Bethany thought CeCe was Alison for some time. Bethany probably figured out that CeCe wasn't really Alison, which is why she started talking **** about her on the tapes. Bethany pretended to still be friends with CeCe so she could get out and kill her for lying to her on Labor Day (she wrote to "Alison" (CeCe) before Labor Day thanking her for the yellow top (that CeCe gave her)). CeCe figured out what she was planning and gave herself, Alison (the note her mom supposedly left with her top was fake), and Bethany the yellow top. Bethany knew "Alison" (CeCe) was going to wear the yellow top that night, so that's all she was looking for. She saw the back of Alison and assumed it CeCe, so she hit her with the rock. Then Mrs. DiLaurentis buried Alison assuming she was dead already to protect Bethany since Bethany didn't know that was the real Alison. CeCe saw all of this happen, which is what she planned. Later on, CeCe killed Bethany before she could expose her and Melissa buried her. CeCe was blackmailing Mrs. DiLaurentis because Mrs. DiLaurentis knew the truth about everything, but she also buried her daughter, so she was forced to protect CeCe by allowing her to live in her house as Red Coat, as well as giving her those clothes in the woods in 4x24. When Alison was discovered to be alive, Mrs. DiLaurentis didn't have anything to hide anymore, so she was going to expose CeCe. That's when CeCe killed her.

Also, everyone that knew the truth about how Marion died is now dead: Bethany, Wilden, Mrs. DiLaurentis, and Eddie Lamb is missing but probably dead. We know CeCe killed Wilden, so it's safe to assume she killed the rest of the people that knew the truth about Marion's death.

That's my theory as of right now. It's all gonna come back to someone's childhood, so I'm probably not 100% correct.

[KevinKDC]

But why in God's name haven't we seen Bethany's face yet? And why hasn't it been explained why the police mistaken her DNA as Alison's?

[waryofothers]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

But why in God's name haven't we seen Bethany's face yet? And why hasn't it been explained why the police mistaken her DNA as Alison's?

That's what I'm stumped on. They said Alison wouldn't have a twin, but that would be the only way for it to make sense. And they definitely have not shown Bethany's face for a reason.

[KevinKDC]

At this point we should all just forget what Marlene has said and promised. It's a bit contradicting because the only way Bethany has the same DNA as Alison's is if they are twins, but then again some friends of Bethany's visited Rosewood. They should've noticed that Bethany looks a lot like Alison.

Or maybe someone at the police department faked the DNA results. The fact that we haven't seen Bethany's face makes me think that she is someone's twin.

[waryofothers]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

At this point we should all just forget what Marlene has said and promised. It's a bit contradicting because the only way Bethany has the same DNA as Alison's is if they are twins, but then again some friends of Bethany's visited Rosewood. They should've noticed that Bethany looks a lot like Alison.

Or maybe someone at the police department faked the DNA results. The fact that we haven't seen Bethany's face makes me think that she is someone's twin.

Those were Sara Harvey's friends! I don't think Bethany had any friends outside of Radley.

[HEIDI]

I thought it was already revealed that A messed with Bethany's dental records which is how they identified her as Alison?

[Walk_Away21]

This **** has been dragged on so long no one can remember any details

Also, I feel like they were originally going to follow the books with this twin mess. I actually remember like season 2 where Emily was kissing Ali one day, and the next Ali was a mega bitch to her, making it seem like she was bipolar / two different people aka a twin. But hasn't mArlene claimed Ali isn't a twin now? And she is trying to switch up the books.

The dumb thing about a twin at this point would be how would none of the cops / parents / characters known about someone's siblings. I mean, was this alleged twin hidden away since birth!?

[HEIDI]

If PLL followed the books...

Season 1: Remains the same.
Season 2: Mona revealed as A, dies in the finale after falling.
Season 3: Alison's twin is introduced, we find out what happened that night and Ali and her accomplice try to burn the Liars alive in the lodge in the finale.
Season 4: Pretty much the same? Except more people are murdered by Ali.
Season 5: Last season, ends with Alison being institutionalized and her accomplice being arrested.

Would've been a cute show with a lot less mess wrapped in a neat bow.

[fridayteenage]

Yeah but it's still the network's #1 show so why would they want it wrapped up in S5?

[YR.]

Cece is NOT A. NOT even mArlene could give such a bad ending to the show. She is a nobody in the story, she doesn't have a plot and the only reason she is there is to play with the public

Season 6 should be the last tbh

[HEIDI]

Originally posted by YR.

Cece is NOT A. NOT even mArlene could give such a bad ending to the show. She is a nobody in the story, she doesn't have a plot and the only reason she is there is to play with the public

Season 6 should be the last tbh

Every ending at this point would be bad, though. Almost 5 years later and we don't know ****.

[Sasha.]

Originally posted by YR.

Cece is NOT A. NOT even mArlene could give such a bad ending to the show. She is a nobody in the story, she doesn't have a plot and the only reason she is there is to play with the public

Season 6 should be the last tbh

exactly

cece being A would be horrible

[Six]

Watch Emily being A because she wants Ali all to herself

[Mr.Link]

What if Bethany Young is actually Cece? I mean Cece can't be her real name...

[KevinKDC]

Their entire "It isn't important who A is, it's important why A is A" makes me believe it's going to be someone we are going to be disappointed about. In other words I'm not expecting the shock factor when A is revealed. With all the theories floating around on youtube, everyone could be A at this point.

[Sasha.]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Their entire "It isn't important who A is, it's important why A is A" makes me believe it's going to be someone we are going to be disappointed about. In other words I'm not expecting the shock factor when A is revealed. With all the theories floating around on youtube, everyone could be A at this point.

yeah, a ton of people have guessed who A is, but very, very few have guessed the motive

[Surfboardt]

Originally posted by OnlyManInTheWorld

From the interview with Sasha Pieterse:

I do know who this person is, and it's very twisted, and I don't think anyone will see it coming. It's not something that you would expect or even that the viewers would be like, 'Oh, that makes sense.' It's actually very dark, especially for this kind of TV show. I enjoy it, and I think it's got great places to go, and I know the writers are having a ball continuing writing for the sixth season and planning for the seventh season. We're very lucky, and I think the fans, it's literally going to blow their minds.

Either she was told to manipulate us, or the Big A is someone's twin brother or sister .

I already told you guys, Mona is dead. The person we see in the finale tomorrow is Mona's twin whom is Big A. They told us that Big A would be revealed, yet all they reveal is that Mona is alive. That's because it's not Mona duh. It's her twin sister who is also big A.

[KevinKDC]

HOLY ****. That makes total sense if mona has a twin sister omgggg