The numbers are okay. Nothing extraordinary but they're not Bionic-level terrible. She just started promo this week and it's her seventh studio album (sixth when not including holiday albums).
It looks set to be her least successful era but she's sold some 15M albums in the U.S. and her icon status can afford that.
Of course we already have the rather predictable slew of corny shade.
For the educated fans out there, we all know how the sales climate has declined and this is a perfectly respectable debut. Especially considering she has only just started promotion for the album in the U.S this week.
For an under-promoted album with no hit single, this is great.
Her music has sounded the same her entire career. its basic. This was going to happen sooner or later.
Yes. Because Thankful sounds exactly like My December who sounds exactly like Stronger and Piece By Piece. You're so insightful and accurate with your assessment of Kelly's discography. Please tell us more.
It's bad, but it could be worse, all things considered. The Christina and Kesha fans, of all people, trying to shade this.
They're the only two stanbases trying to throw shade. They better get their life cuz even in Q1, Piece By Piece is about to outsell efforts from 2012 that were released with Black Friday in mind.
The numbers are okay. Nothing extraordinary but they're not Bionic-level terrible. She just started promo this week and it's her seventh studio album (sixth when not including holiday albums).
It looks set to be her least successful era but she's sold some 15M albums in the U.S. and her icon status can afford that.
Kelly should have done more signed albums to get my coins 
They better get their life cuz even in Q1, Piece By Piece is about to outsell efforts from 2012 that were released with Black Friday in mind. 
@ pitchy strippers outselling her