[Giselle]

No, ARTPOP was a flop. That's been determined quite some time ago. Speak Now and ARTPOP aren't really comparable lol, don't try that again.

4 also sold double ARTPOP, so how exactly was it a flop if CHARTDROP was an underperformance? Manster logic never works.

[madonnas]

4 is a flop for Bey's standards

[Bounce]

Originally posted by BritKing

How is 4 a flop when it sold more than 2 of those albums listed?

4 sales right now is not bad but back in 2011 it was bad.

Born This Way 7m
Teenage Dream 6m+
Loud 6m+
The Truth About Love 6m+

and then Beyonce came with 3m the difference is 3m/4m

[madonnas]

But it doesn't really matter since it's still a relevant album.

[ezra]

wow. instantly turned off drop that kitty and listened to this instead. charli really wishes she was fame-era gaga.

[ezra]

Femme Fatale was a flop. 4 was not a flop lol

[Bounce]

Originally posted by Giselle

No, ARTPOP was a flop. That's been determined quite some time ago. Speak Now and ARTPOP aren't really comparable lol, don't try that again.

4 also sold double ARTPOP, so how exactly was it a flop if CHARTDROP was an underperformance? Manster logic never works.

ARTPOP outside of the US 1.2m
BEYONCE outside of the US 1.5m

the difference is one is a flop and the other isn't not to mention all of her peers sold 1m+ more than her with their "SMASH ALBUMS!!11"

Speak Now was a flop outside of the US

[Willy.]

Originally posted by Bounce

4 sales right now is not bad but back in 2011 it was bad.

Born This Way 7m
Teenage Dream 6m+
Loud 6m+
The Truth About Love 6m+

and then Beyonce came with 3m the difference is 3m/4m

4 wasn't exactly this mainstream-sounding album, though.

[Vin]

Me when I read posts from monsters trying to convince everyone that Gaga is talented and successful.



...Vin

[Sinister]

Originally posted by RudeBoyy

Natalie's is the low budget safe Tinashe. Don't bring GODriana into this.

she will blow up around the world

[Giselle]

Originally posted by Bounce

ARTPOP outside of the US 1.2m
BEYONCE outside of the US 1.5m

the difference is one is a flop and the other isn't not to mention all of her peers sold 1m+ more than her with their "SMASH ALBUMS!!11"

Speak Now was a flop outside of the US

Considering the USA is the most important music market, why exactly aren't you including US sales in this?

The way Mansters manipulate things to make it look like Gaga is 'right below her peers!!1!'

[RudeBoyy]

Originally posted by Willy.

My Everything is only at 1.2M WW. Again, with the amount of promotion and global smashes, that's pretty dismal.

But I mean it's expected that a Hip-Hop album would go on to outsell My Everything.

Ok Ariana's sales are kinda awful given Scooter's DETERMINATION to shove her down everyone's throat. Idk how they make any money at all with all those a-list producers and HUGE promo & that fake as TRL return all for such awful sales.

Originally posted by iHype.

You're right, it's fully bad.

Will Usher even be allowed to release an album?

[iHype.]

QUESTION	CHECKLIST
One Top 10?	✔
Two Top 10's?	✔
Three Top 10's?	✔
Four Top 10's?	✔
VMA Performance?	✔
...2nd VMA performance for Bang Bang?	✔
SNL Performance?	✔
AMA Performance?	✔
Radio Disney Music Awards Performance?	✔
2015 NBA All Star Game Performance?	✔
GRAMMYs performance?	✔
iHeart Radio Ball Performance?	✔
Z100 Jingle Ball performance?	✔
VH1's 4th of July Jam performance?	✔
Total Ariana Live Special + Performance on MTV?	✔
Dancing With the Stars performance?	✔
Billboard Music Awards performance?	✔
Jimmy Kemmel performance?	✔
Victoria Fashion Show performance?	✔
Disney Parks performer?	✔
Jimmy Fallon performance?	✔
Album discounted multiple times?	✔
Deluxe edition released?	✔
5 singles released?	✔
4 Top 10 Singles at Radio?	✔
Acting Roles on TV + Movies?	✔
Tour announced + starting?	✔
Album sold 600k to date yet?	✖

"The album is selling good"

[Skywalker]

[Bounce]

Originally posted by Giselle

Considering the USA is the most important music market, why exactly aren't you including US sales in this?

The way Mansters manipulate things to make it look like Gaga is 'right below her peers!!1!'

Fine ARTPOP was a flop in the US but outside of it, it wasn't

[BritKing]

If ARTPOP is an under-performance then FF is certainly not a flop considering it sold around the same and scored more hits.

[alkralkra]

Originally posted by Bounce

4 sales right now is not bad but back in 2011 it was bad.

Born This Way 7m
Teenage Dream 6m+
Loud 6m+
The Truth About Love 6m+

and then Beyonce came with 3m the difference is 3m/4m

Those are all massively successful albums. 4 sold moderately.

[ezra]

omg at ARTPOP outselling Fatte Female

[Bounce]

Originally posted by BritKing

If ARTPOP is an under-performance then FF is certainly not a flop considering it sold around the same and scored more hits.

FF isn't really a flop.

But I'm still shocked when I found out about HIAM sales

[Skywalker]

Artpop was an underperformance until halfway into the 'Do What U Want' run when she gave up on the album, fled to Little Monsters.com for a solid two or three months, and went on another public shutout. Then tried rising it back from the dead with G.U.Y. randomly a few months after that.

Still love Godga though. There's a reason she's my number one fave.