[CaptainMusic]

Originally posted by RichGirlPlanet

Stay is a bigger classic than Diamonds and WFL.

Diamonds maybe.

WFL? No

[slobro]

Poker Face and Just Dance have the highest post-chartrun/catalog sales out of all these pop girl songs

Facts > biased anecdotal 'receipts'

[Slayley]

How did 21 debut with 352k in mid-january without a hit single (yet) and when 19 kinda flopped w/o 21's later success?

[thirdward]

Originally posted by Shapes

come @ me

Rihanna has a lot of songs that were really popular but when it comes to "classics" she has We Found Love and arguably Umbrella. Diamonds wasn't that impactful, I don't hear anyone talk about it, it's never on the radio. Stay was easily the bigger hit

"shine bright like a diamond" > stay, wfl and umbrella

[Kayhan]

Originally posted by santos

Angelina is giving me Gaga teas. It's obvious she's faking cause the Unbroken mixed reviews, like Gaga faked her injury cause of poor ticket sales

PFF do you really still believe this

[ToLove]

Just Dance is still Gaga's best song. Why the **** do her remaining fans pay it dust?

[Instant]

I think Diamonds is the most popular Rih song in Russia. She is so huge here and she'll never come here

[Slayley]

Originally posted by ToLove

Just Dance is still Gaga's best song. Why the **** do her remaining fans pay it dust?

+1, I don't get them at all

[ToLove]

Originally posted by Slayley

How did 21 debut with 352k in mid-january without a hit single (yet) and when 19 kinda flopped w/o 21's later success?

19 ended up selling 7 million copies+. As of now, it's still ahead of the Frozen soundtrack.

[youkneekorn]

CharliXCX is such a Godney stan. She thanked her in her album.

[Shapes]

Originally posted by ToLove

19 ended up selling 7 million copies+. As of now, it's still ahead of the Frozen soundtrack.

yeah but the bulk of them were sold post-21

[thirdward]

y all the Diamonds hate?

...wyd

[Slayley]

Originally posted by ToLove

19 ended up selling 7 million copies+. As of now, it's still ahead of the Frozen soundtrack.

Yeah but 19 peaked and sold a lot due to the success of 21

[Instant]

Originally posted by Slayley

+1, I don't get them at all

Most of monsters stan for Crapsy and think that ARTPOP is a decent album
Yep, JD is very underrated

[Nippy'sReceipts]

Umbrella is so forgotten imo.
I've barely heard it at all post-2008.

At least I hear Disturbia at every Halloween event/ party. And I think it was in a commercial or something ?

[Giselle]

Originally posted by slobro

Poker Face and Just Dance have the highest post-chartrun/catalog sales out of all these pop girl songs

Facts > biased anecdotal 'evidence'

That's the problem with arguing about classics. Numbers don't make anything classic/iconic/legendary.

[Lord Blackout]

Get the Party Started has 10m views.
I would hardly call it a classic

[Halien4Life]

kworb, since you read the book and considering it's a SYG stable at this point. What are your thoughts on Gaga Gurl the movie ?

[Ozzy8923]

Originally posted by Slayley

How did 21 debut with 352k in mid-january without a hit single (yet) and when 19 kinda flopped w/o 21's later success?

Adele won a Grammy for 19 in 2010 so that was probably her first big exposure in the US and Chasing Pavements had become a 'hit' (using the term loosely) after 19 came out so it was just a matter of increased exposure following 19 and 21 having better promotion in the US. Rolling In the Deep might not have been a hit yet, but it was already her biggest single in the States when 21 came out.

[Skywalker]

I hate Diamonds because of that hook, one of the worst in pop history and it doesn't help that she sounds like a gremlin. Stay is a beautiful song that is relevant to every single soul and has a gorgeous melody.

Anyways, Just Dance is Godga's best classic. That is true and Monsters shouldn't deny it. If ALEJANDRO was more remembered, however, it would be instead.