[GypsyLife]

Don't come for Gypsy when even the critics ate it.

"Gypsy" received generally positive reviews from music critics. Adam Markovitz from Entertainment Weekly considered the track one of the album's best, calling it "enjoyable".[5] Matt Russoniello from Celebuzz called "Gypsy" the new "The Edge of Glory", noting similarities to Gaga's 2011 song, and suggesting the possibility of the former becoming a single in the future.[19] Caryn Ganz from Rolling Stone praised the song's simple lyrics, describing it as an "Eighties-style anthem where Gaga admits her love of performing."Chris Bosman from Time magazine, thought that "Gypsy" serves as the "epic end-of-album track" along with "Dope"."

Would the critics lie?

[Brunette Ambition]

Originally posted by GypsyLife

That's the only song that would actually do well on the radio (not counting DWUW and Applause).

Originally posted by GypsyLife

Gyspy would have done better then G.U.Y.

Music not the Bling

Originally posted by Frozen99

G.U.Y. > Gypsy

[Mariano]

Originally posted by toanythingtaboo

I guess the winning formula is picking something distinctive, something ownable, something attractive and something people can imitate.

The Italian Curls wig is consistent, but it's really Cher...so seeing a drag queen wearing it (for instance) doesn't immediately say Gaga.

If the next album is pop/rock, then I definitely think she should be able to present a new, memorable look. For instance - what if she opts for the anti-Fame in the sense that she always has black hair, perhaps with the fringe and/or hairbow, and pairs a distinctive eye make up style with her septum piercing? She's done these things before, but only experts would remember because she hasn't really done it in major performances or videos...and even when she did, she immediately confused the look with 10 others.

That kind of goth-punk-glamour isn't strongly associated to one pop girl, so she could own it with consistency and appeal.

I need her to keep this kind of looks:







She looks beautiful, unique and Gaga and at the same time different (which nowadays is hard for Gaga, cuz people expect everything)

Especially the first one, it's flawless.

[z10]

^^^ i agree

[Mariano]

Gypsy >>>>>>>>>>>>> G.U.Y.

But both are amazing, I don't get the hate for either of them (especially G.U.Y. Since its more hated) ... G.U.Y. is so good, the beat is a MURDERER.

[Phoenixstar]

Please stop fighting between G.U.Y. and Gypsy

They both are amazing and great and highlight of the track/record
So, G.U.Y. = Gypsy

[Mariano]

Though if G.U.Y. wasn't released and didn't flop, it wouldn't be half as hated.

[rasmushooker]

Lady Gaga - UrbanGA EP

Animal
Let Them Hoes Fight
Out Of Control
Cake Like Lady Gaga
Reloaded
Take You OUT
Bitch Don't Kill My Vibe

[Futile Odds]

Always disliked G.U.Y. and found it a terrible single choice. I swear it cursed me with health issues when it finally came out as a single and flopped. Her revenge was real.

[DonnieDarko]

Originally posted by GypsyLife

Gyspy would have done better then G.U.Y.

G.U.Y. is a better song

Two different things.


G.U.Y. is miles better.

[DonnieDarko]

Originally posted by Mariano

Though if G.U.Y. wasn't released and didn't flop, it wouldn't be half as hated.

BINGO!

[lilrobomonster]

OMG I finally got my copy of the target version of C2C. The bonus tracks are so fun! Even Tony is giving me a pep in my step!

[rasmushooker]

Y'all wanna discuss Gaga's worst song but this takes the cake. Sounds like an
cheap italian commercial background beat. Glad that this is an demo.

[GypsyLife]

Originally posted by DonnieDarko

Two different things.


G.U.Y. is miles better.

I understand it's a fan fave but maybe I am too straight to understand a power buttom song

[DonnieDarko]

Originally posted by lilrobomonster

OMG I finally got my copy of the target version of C2C. The bonus tracks are so fun! Even Tony is giving me a pep in my step!

Yay!

[DonnieDarko]

Originally posted by GypsyLife

I understand it's a fan fave but maybe I am too straight to understand a power buttom song

Believe it or not, I'm also straight. I just like gay songs.

[Alchemist]

I still need the Target version of C2C, bewitched bothered and bewildered is life

[GypsyLife]

For anyone interested about the songs that are being played before the ArtRave:

[rasmushooker]

Originally posted by GypsyLife

For anyone interested about the songs that are being played before the ArtRave:

OOOMG. You don't know how much I have been looking for those.

[hairofglory]

Gyspy would have definitely done better than GUY. I don't understand, does her team/Interscope not do research on these things? Literally all non fans irl that I know and have heard Gyspy love it. Oh well. Missed opportunity.