I'd say the GP hates Gaga. She's always been "try hard" and "pretentious" but she was mystifying and had undeniably catchy music. People got fed up with trying to understand her and so now she's pretty tired, but I don't really mind that. I am here for her making an album that really highlights all her strengths as a musician
I'm also not seeing how her recent choreography has been a mess. Well live, yeah sure I guess, but her dancing in videos is probably one of the few things Gaga has evolved in, as a performer, since her debut.