[Rider]

Originally posted by Summerboy95

And those who gave her a 9-10??

Yes, I gave her a 10. I'm aware she's not a 10 but I'm just doing it to balance all those trolls that give her 1. Stop being so confused.

[Dollas n Diamonds]

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

No.. the OP shouldn't put her there from the start. The same with Beyonce.
How can you judge someone based on skills that they don't even exploit?

tbh. it should have be Ester

[Cola.drinker]

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

And all those who gave her 1, based on what lyrics are you givin' that 1?
A mess

So we should give her 0 ? Ok I will edit my post.

[Vespertine]

???

Are you trying to get her bullied or?? Obviously she doesn't belong in this thread

EDIT: Wait The OP:

Mariah Carey = 9.11
Taylor Swift = 8.23
Lana del Rey = 8.09
Lorde = 8.04
P!nk = 7.69
Katy Perry = 6.29
Beyonce = 4.07

ATRL is a damn mess.

[Rider]

Originally posted by Cola.drinker

So we should give her 0 ? Ok I will edit my post.

As you wish.

[superben]

Why is this reported?

She takes part in song-writing, right? She's eligible for this thread.

And I'm not trying to bully her at all I like Rih. She might not be a strong writer, but what I am trying to do here is to cover all the popular artists plus others, so she's just one of those that we can rate on for a period.

[Vertigo Stick]

Originally posted by Vespertine

???

Are you trying to get her bullied or?? Obviously she doesn't belong in this thread

EDIT: Wait The OP:



ATRL is a damn mess.

[Tigre]

Mariah and Taylor leading well deserved.

Rihanna? Um....a 2. I stan but clearly not for songwriting.

[Vespertine]

Originally posted by superben

Why is this reported?

She takes part in song-writing, right? She's eligible for this thread.

And I'm not trying to bully her at all I like Rih. She might not be a strong writer, but what I am trying to do here is to cover all the popular artists plus others, so she's just one of those that we can rate on for a period.

How could you possibly discern her songwriting ability from the very little input she has had in her music though?

[ComeToAnEnd]

1 .

[TheRoofInhabitant]

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

And all those who gave her 1, based on what lyrics are you givin' that 1?
A mess

I did because, even though I like Rih, she's not a songwriter and rarely takes part in the creative process of her albums. She shouldn't have been mentioned here in first place.

[Rider]

Originally posted by TheRoofInhabitant

I did because, even though I like Rih, she's not a songwriter and rarely takes part in the creative process of her albums. She shouldn't have been mentioned here in first place.

Well yeah, I understand. But since y'all are saying she's not a songwriter why rate her 0 or 1 when you should not rate her at all, as she's not a songwriter

[Junlin]

3

[Superpower]

0

[superben]

I'm giving Rih a 5

[swissman]

1.

[OreGuy]

Give me an example of songs she wrote.

However, I will give her 1, since I've read a lot here that she don't write her music and just literally sing the songs given to her.

[toanythingtaboo]

I'll give her the benefit of a doubt.

2.

[GiftFromGod]

MESS @ THIS THREAD BEING REPORTED WHEN IT'S RIH'S TURN. BYE.





Anyways, 2.

[TheRoofInhabitant]

Originally posted by EmRiNavy

Well yeah, I understand. But since y'all are saying she's not a songwriter why rate her 0 or 1 when you should not rate her at all, as she's not a songwriter

You're right actually, I take my vote back