But she freestyled the verses on Partition?
Y'all keep losing arguments and it's quite embarrassing
It really is. Sad a woman has the much control over people. Here we have people who worked with her saying she does. They're "trying" to say she doesn't She still cashing them checks
No it is not irrelevant because here we have someone who has worked with Beyonce, who has been through a situation where songwriting credits were in question, and who has clarified that Beyonce does indeed write songs and that if he were to go to the washroom, he would be afraid that she would complete the song herself.
Just because you don't want to talk about anything aside from Irreplaceable doesn't mean this is irrelevant lol.
Because the only clear evidence that we have of the fruits of that songwriting session with Mrs. Carter happened to be stolen and he gave interviews confirming that he did write the song for himself. So, it's irrelevant as I said.
lol No way they're gonna answer this question, they will still claim that Bey is a songwriter despite the fact that she doesn't write lyrics, the most integral part of songwriting.
The most integral part of songwriting is making MUSIC, hence why it's called SONGwriting. Songs are PERFORMED because they have MUSIC. There are songs that exist without any words, but lyrics without music aren't actually songs. Whoops.
Beyonce writes the melody, hums along while changing a word here or there, and expecting a full songwriting credit like she did heavy lifting is so inauthentic. She's a singer. She's good with singing. She should just stick to that and stop claiming others work as her own.
Whoever said Beyonce can't write melodies is completely delusional. Beyonce is a musical prodigy, and she's worked extremely hard to get where she is today. Give credit when it's due, haters.
Because the only clear evidence that we have of the fruits of that songwriting session with Mrs. Carter happened to be stolen and he gave interviews confirming that he did write the song for himself. So, it's irrelevant as I said.
Beyonce said she wrote it in concert once, and in print in the album notes it says she didn't. Where is the stealing? And how is Ne-Yo's firsthand account not clear evidence?
"By now Beyoncé was really producing the group. They were buying tracks from highly qualified programmers and writing words for them."
"When she got here, she would immediately start writing lyrics for the song and finish it right there in front of me".
"For the song 'Bootylicious' she wrote all the lyrics for it right in our Studio A. Then she taught the song to Kelly and Michelle, and all three of them worked on the vocals together."
"In addition to being impressed with Beyonce's on-the-spot skills as a lyricist and producer, Workman also was awestruck by certain aspects of her musicianship, particularly regarding timing." -Gold Star/SugarHill Recording Studios Memoirs
Beyonce, like Madonna, Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera etc is not a songwriter by profession. They know this. Only their most deluded fans dispute this.
It really is. Sad a woman has the much control over people. Here we have people who worked with her saying she does. They're "trying" to say she doesn't She still cashing them checks
they stay bringing up BC Jean tho who really was only mad because Bey made it a single without asking
Because these people have already made up their mind and they won't read or believe the facts right in front of their eyes. They would rather believe some fiction.
These people hate everything Bey does, even her next album, they hate it already even though they haven't heard a single thing about it. It's unhealthy tbh.
"By now Beyoncé was really producing the group. They were buying tracks from highly qualified programmers and writing words for them."
"When she got here, she would immediately start writing lyrics for the song and finish it right there in front of me".
"For the song 'Bootylicious' she wrote all the lyrics for it right in our Studio A. Then she taught the song to Kelly and Michelle, and all three of them worked on the vocals together."
"In addition to being impressed with Beyonce's on-the-spot skills as a lyricist and producer, Workman also was awestruck by certain aspects of her musicianship, particularly regarding timing." -Gold Star/SugarHill Recording Studios Memoirs
The most integral part of songwriting is making MUSIC, hence why it's called SONGwriting. Songs are PERFORMED because they have MUSIC. There are songs that exist without any words, but lyrics without music aren't actually songs. Whoops.
She still cashing them checks 
