[Jackson]

Consistency, multiple peaks, lack of overexposure, and an overall better discography

[Funhouse]

Originally posted by Prismatic

Fun fact :
Pink's greatest hits outsold Avril, Britney and Chrstina's latest studio albums combined.

Poor them

[Adele Addict]

She's a bigger touring force because she puts on far better shows than any of the others and bothers to sing live (ahem, Britney), and she's incredibly talented and has more versatility as an artist. Britney doesn't really care about her career anymore, and she can't even sing. Sorry, not trying to shade Britney, but it's obvious. She doesn't sing live at her own shows, she didn't even sing on the studio recordings of some of her own songs. As for Christina Aguilera, her vocal talent is incredible but the promo for her last era wasn't very good and overall, I don't think Christina had as many singles that appealed to the general public as P!nk. As for Avril, the promotion for her albums has been awful for specifically Goodbye Lullaby and Avril Lavigne, and her live shows are a mess. She plays random songs from her first few albums that weren't singles OR fan favorites, like "I Always Get What I Want". And she doesn't have as much versatility as P!nk.

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by Prismatic

Fun fact :
Pink's greatest hits outsold Avril, Britney and Chrstina's latest studio albums combined.

P!nk's greatest hits album had 2 singles and promo.
Britney's latest studio album had 2 singles and no promo
Christina's latest studio album had 1 single and limited promo

P!nk's sales are amazing and admirable, but there's no reason to use them against other albums which had messy campaigns and no marketing plan.

[NoaHx]

DEATH @ people saying this dude is more talented than Christina, more than other two I agree, but than Christina NOT. They have equal talent and this talk is useless since the ones who like him and are Christina's haters will say so. But I have to agree his songs have more appeal nowadays. His albums and the public speak for themselves.

[Funhouse]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

P!nk's greatest hits album had 2 singles and promo.
Britney's latest studio album had 2 singles and no promo
Christina's latest studio album had 1 single and limited promo

P!nk's sales are amazing and admirable, but there's no reason to use them against other albums which had messy campaigns and no marketing plan.

Refresh my memory please, I only recall an interview on Ellen (to announce her Pregnancy), some radio interview ft. Christina, and one Raise Your Glass performance. What other promo has she done?

[NoaHx]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

P!nk's greatest hits album had 2 singles and promo.
Britney's latest studio album had 2 singles and no promo
Christina's latest studio album had 1 single and limited promo

P!nk's sales are amazing and admirable, but there's no reason to use them against other albums which had messy campaigns and no marketing plan.

You know they'll use any excuse to put our girl down, sis. Don't bother.

[Eternium]

Originally posted by Prismatic

Fun fact :
Pink's greatest hits outsold Avril, Britney and Chrstina's latest studio albums combined.

Fun fact:
Britney's Greatest Hits outsold P!nk's despite never getting a single promo performance

[Thor]

She has most definitely NOT outlasted Britney

NO Ma'm

Britney just had 1 underperforming album after 15 years of slayage, dont do too much!

[Prismy]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

P!nk's greatest hits album had 2 singles and promo.
Britney's latest studio album had 2 singles and no promo
Christina's latest studio album had 1 single and limited promo

P!nk's sales are amazing and admirable, but there's no reason to use them against other albums which had messy campaigns and no marketing plan.

Yeah if Lotus had the promo GHSF had (which is 1 AMAs performance and some interviews here and there) it would magically sell 3m more.

[Thor]

Originally posted by Eternium

Fun fact:
Britney's Greatest Hits outsold P!nk's despite never getting a single promo performance

Educate em Sis

[ahauntingnearu]

Originally posted by NoaHx

DEATH @ people saying this dude is more talented than Christina, more than other two I agree, but than Christina NOT. They have equal talent and this talk is useless since the ones who like him and are Christina's haters will say so. But I have to agree his songs have more appeal nowadays. His albums and the public speak for themselves.

Repulsive tbh

[KatyLegendperry]

Because she's never been that big so she's never gotten overexposed, she doesn't have any haters, and everyone enjoys/respects her and her music.

[phonpei05]

Pink stays safe with her music (pop/punk/rock) and it is much more relatable.

[TheVoiceXtina]

The audacity when Christina gracefully allowed her to be a part of Lady Marmalade, setting her up for the big leagues and giving P!nk her first grammy. Shameful.

[Funhouse]

Originally posted by Eternium

Fun fact:
Britney's Greatest Hits outsold P!nk's despite never getting a single promo performance

Britney's greatest hits was released in a much better sales climate and has been available for 6 years longer than P!nk's, of course it sold more. This is besides the point though, because the question was why p!nk outlasted the other girls, not why britney did better 10 years ago

[Lucas32]

Originally posted by Eternium

Fun fact:
Britney's Greatest Hits outsold P!nk's despite never getting a single promo performance

It was released in 2004 and P!nk's in 2010

[Prismy]

Originally posted by Eternium

Fun fact:
Britney's Greatest Hits outsold P!nk's despite never getting a single promo performance

Britney's was released in 2004/05 while Pink's in 2010/11. The sales climate has obviously changed a lot over the years.

[dfantasy]

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

The audacity when Christina gracefully allowed her to be a part of Lady Marmalade, setting her up for the big leagues and giving P!nk her first grammy. Shameful.

The insolence when P!nk basically shaped and handed Stripped to Christina.

[TheVoiceXtina]

It's like you get a few hits and automatically think you can compete with the big girls. Consistent career, but that's it. She will never experience the highs the latter three had.

Anyway, Christina won't ever be over stupid. She's an American institution and global icon. A true pioneer in her field.