[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Proves my point.

I don't remember you making the point that ARTPOP is possibly the biggest bomb since... forever.

[Dollas n Diamonds]

Originally posted by aayAlex

Whites WIN again!

Rih beats Beyst tho

Originally posted by Lord Blackout

Omg

It would be even funnier if her brain were functioning

I feel awful for laughing at that

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Not Gaga's bombing being a ridiculous excuse for ATRL members to dismiss a 125 million records career, 400 million in tour grossing and the accomplishments your faves will never achieve. Not people forgeting Rihanna's constant bombing and single's underperformance, Bey's 4 era, Pink's non existent career until recently, Nicki's non existent career in general and many more..

Pls stop you're just making the situation worse

[Liberdade mi amor]

Originally posted by Nicole

She's over. Wake up already, it's annoying and embarrassing at this point

Yeah, yeah. And I have to take Nicole's word for it. Cause Nicole is the one who hold the business' future in her keybord. And after all.. you know what. yeah she is over.

[Whatevaaaaa]

Originally posted by satellites.™

If I was talking about albums she would still lose.

And no Taylor has not even come close to spending more weeks in the top 10 than Beyonce.

Taylor - 72 weeks
Beyonce - 148 weeks (261 with DC)

Poor you.

148 weeks back then and now she struggles for one.
Time may change bey, but she can't change time

[onna]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Not Gaga's bombing being a ridiculous excuse for ATRL members to dismiss a 125 million records career, 400 million in tour grossing and the accomplishments your faves will never achieve. Not people forgeting Rihanna's constant bombing and single's underperformance, Bey's 4 era, Pink's non existent career until recently, Nicki's non existent career in general and many more..

Everyone you mentioned lastest era performed better than Gaga's [with the exception of Nicki. Idk her stats] but anyway no one is dismissing her stats, people would just rather focus on her current era which just so happens to be bombing

[Nialler]

the meltdown

[slobro]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

Rihanna produced at least one #1 since her second era; outside of Try This, P!nk has done well for herself and nothing from the 4 era has bombed as badly as "G.U.Y." and 4 is a Platinum-selling album. ARTPOP is a bomb.

-The era is going like Rated R. Applause will go on to sell 3 million, and DWUW went platinum. G.U.Y. is just the Rockstar 101 of this era
-Outside of ARTPOP, Gaga has done well
-2.3 million in this market is not much worse (if at all) than 3.1 million back in 2011. Applause is bigger than all 10 singles from 4 combined. Lastly ARTPOP made the IFPI and 4 didn't.

[Braz]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Yeah, yeah. And I have to take Nicole's word for it. Cause Nicole is the one who hold the business' future in her keybord. And after all.. you know what. yeah she is over.

Proves ur point.

[Nicole]

Originally posted by Liberdade mi amor

Yeah, yeah. And I have to take Nicole's word for it. Cause Nicole is the one who hold the business' future in her keybord. And after all.. you know what. yeah she is over.

Thank you for finally accepting how it works.

[Nialler]

Originally posted by slobro

-The era is going like Rated R. Applause will go on to sell 3 million, and DWUW went platinum. G.U.Y. is just the Rockstar 101 of this era
-Outside of ARTPOP, Gaga has done well
-2.3 million in this market is not much worse (if at all) than 3.1 million back in 2011. ARTPOP made the IFPI and 4 didn't. And Applause is bigger than all 10 singles from 4 combined

lmao, keep clinging to those huge overshipments if this makes you sleep well

[iheartBrit]

I'm shocked ARTPOP sold 2.3 million copies. I thought it was much lower.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by slobro

-The era is going like Rated R. Applause will go on to sell 3 million, and DWUW went platinum. G.U.Y. is just the Rockstar 101 of this era
-Outside of ARTPOP, Gaga has done well
-ARTPOP made the IFPI and 4 didn't. 2.3 million in this market is not much worse (if at all) than 3.1 million back in 2011

Stop these lies. Rated R didn't bomb as badly as ARTPOP. ARTPOP will max out at around 2.7 million.

I'm not even Nicole or JLips trolling. Call ARTPOP what it is. A flop.

[SupahBass05]

ARTPOP sold 1.7 didn't it? 2.3 sounds like a made up Interscope #! The lone meltdown

[onna]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

I'm shocked ARTPOP sold 2.3 million copies. I thought it was much lower.

It is, those are shipments

[Nialler]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

I'm shocked ARTPOP sold 2.3 million copies. I thought it was much lower.

it sold 1.6 million so far

[Whatevaaaaa]

You guys don't realize that many a superstar has had a flop era much, much bigger than ARTPOP and came back.
Maybe none in recent memory but has an icon bigger than Gaga been made anytime in the recent past? Nope!
She is going nowhere.

[Liberdade mi amor]

Originally posted by Nicole

Thank you for finally accepting how it works.

Welp, slay

[Gagasm]

I'm just mad Godspy didn't get a release

[Nicole]

Originally posted by slobro

-The era is going like Rated R. Applause will go on to sell 3 million, and DWUW went platinum. G.U.Y. is just the Rockstar 101 of this era
-Outside of ARTPOP, Gaga has done well
-2.3 million in this market is not much worse (if at all) than 3.1 million back in 2011. Applause is bigger than all 10 singles from 4 combined. Lastly ARTPOP made the IFPI and 4 didn't.

Sorry but you're too smart for that.