[Nerevanin]

Kelly for me by far, atlhough I use Taylor.

To the person which tries to compare the gurls' song-writing skills by posting a song written by Taylor and Kelly's Stronger which wasn't written by Kelly: Really?

And WANEGBT is like the most stupid song ever and Taylor lost quite a lot of respect from me because of the song. Don't even try to compare it to anything from Kelly's catalogue.

Originally posted by BlueMoon77

Your whole response is contradicting. So she wrote the lyrics by herself, but had cowriters??. "The cowriter is usually the one who came up with the music" You just said SHE writes the melodies??. And How exactly do you write melodies without playing a musical instrument I'm very confused here.

Tell me: Can a person sing without playing an instrument? Yes, it's possible. And tada!!! Here is the answer how she can write a melody without playing an instrument. I hope you're not very confused anymore.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Dead at natural vocal chords not being considered an instrument.

Kelly Clarkson is the greater artist in every conceivable way possible. Taylor has always been a nonfactor outside the Country world unless she rides momentum from either a first single or a single that coincides with a broken relationship that is well covered in the tabloids.

[WayTooHonest13]

Kelly slays Taylor in terms of album sales, single sales, critical acclaim, touring, and writing.

[stayfly]

Of course you can create melodies with nothing but your voice as an instrument.

I think Taylor's overall discography is more consistent.

I choose Kelly because the combination of vocal prowess and beauty and raw emotional honesty slays me. As exemplified here in this song she wrote:

[henryevil]

For me it was Kelly in the early 00s, but Taylor now

[Ressti]

Kelly in every way.

When will Taylor TBFH


This song still slays me

[boodytay]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Dead at natural vocal chords not being considered an instrument.

Kelly Clarkson is the greater artist in every conceivable way possible. Taylor has always been a nonfactor outside the Country world unless she rides momentum from either a first single or a single that coincides with a broken relationship that is well covered in the tabloids.

Taylor remains the most talented artist overall (even if Kelly can play one instrument better than Taylor ); she has the better lyrics, production and melodies. And Taylor always is a factor sweetheart, not 'cause of a failed relationship or a smash single, her existence just gets more coverage than Kelly when she's absolutely doing nothing. She inspires countless think-pieces published all the time by countless publications, analyzing her lyrics, her influences, her impact and her image. Why is that? Because she has infinitely more depth. And this is why she's the superior artist.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by WayTooHonest13

Kelly slays Taylor in terms of album sales, single sales, critical acclaim, touring, and writing.

[Pristine]

Taylor is a much better songwriter and performer. Kelly has a huge voice but has nothing else going for her. Time will easily put Taylor in the lead by a mile (and I'm not talking this poll, I'm talking about global domination).

[Pristine]

Originally posted by WayTooHonest13

Kelly slays Taylor in terms of album sales, single sales, critical acclaim, touring, and writing.

you got to be trolling?

[BlueMoon77]

Originally posted by miley rayy

did I really read that WANEGBT is better than Stronger? I mean Stronger isn't a masterpiece but WANEGBT is a ridiculous and stupid song.

I prefer Kelly. I use both but in the end it's Kelly's voice and personality that makes me like her more.

Nnnnnn

No sweetie. Can you give a reason as to why Stronger is a better song?? Id also love to know what makes Taylor's song so "stupid" exactly?? That sounds like a really childish remark to make.

Every pop girl has done a song like Stronger, just another cliche and bland electro- pop song that has been done over and over again. Can anybody please tell me what is so special about the damn song?? There's not ONE memorable thing about it

[Schhh]

Kelly.

[Troye]

Originally posted by BlueMoon77

Nnnnnn

No sweetie. Can you give a reason as to why Stronger is a better song?? Id also love to know what makes Taylor's song so "stupid" exactly?? That sounds like a really childish remark to make.

Every pop girl has done a song like Stronger, just another cliche and bland electro- pop song that has been done over and over again. Can anybody please tell me what is so special about the damn song?? There's not ONE memorable thing about it

I hope you know it wasn't written by Kelly though.

Anyway, I think it's just that I prefer Stronger over WANEGBT simply because of the theme and the pop-rock sound. I like Taylor alot (I think Speak Now is a superior record overall compared to Red and against Stronger lyrically).

Probably nothing that makes it exceptional. As far as that goes, I think it's just that it's Kelly's biggest hit by far in this digital age. At least for me.

[Giselle]

Taylor. Kelly sucks. Taylor makes her songs relatable without being cheesy.

[WayTooHonest13]

The "Oh uh-Woah's" in the background of Treacherous alone completely demolish anything Kelly has ever done and will ever do.

[abrahamjmr]

The one with a great voice.

[vinKC]

Voice: Kelly
Performance: Taylor
Songwriting: Taylor
Songs: Kelly
Personality: Kelly
Likeability: Kelly

Of course I prefer Kelly, but I love Red.

[vinKC]

Originally posted by WayTooHonest13

The "Oh uh-Woah's" in the background of Treacherous alone completely demolish anything Kelly has ever done and will ever do.

LOL.

[Mhs90]

Originally posted by muddysquirrel

What exactly makes Taylor sour? The fact that she is a woman who dares to paint those poor helpless men in a negative light in some of her songs? The fact that she is such a huge star that its profitable to have some sensationalism angle added to her every story/move? What?

Wanna know why Kelly seems more likable? She lacks starpower. As simple as that. None cares what she does or says.

Kelly has been covering Taylor's songs in her concerts. That tells me she herself has a favorable opinion of Taylor's talent.

She's not likable by GP. Period. You know more about her media coverage than I do.

Starpower has nothing to do with likable factor. Look at Beyonce. She has both.

[BlueMoon77]

Originally posted by Nerevanin

Kelly for me by far, atlhough I use Taylor.

To the person which tries to compare the gurls' song-writing skills by posting a song written by Taylor and Kelly's Stronger which wasn't written by Kelly: Really?

And WANEGBT is like the most stupid song ever and Taylor lost quite a lot of respect from me because of the song. Don't even try to compare it to anything from Kelly's catalogue.



Tell me: Can a person sing without playing an instrument? Yes, it's possible. And tada!!! Here is the answer how she can write a melody without playing an instrument. I hope you're not very confused anymore.

Are you above the age of ten??
Please post me Kelly's best soely-written song. And please don't even try it with Because Of You, because it's too lyrically weak of a song to be comparing it with others.

"WANEGBT" is like the most stupid song ever"


WOW great review as to WHY the song is stupid, very insightful

At least the song is memorable/ risky/ and original unlike Stronger, which ANY pop girl could've done. WANEGBT is one of Taylor's worst songs, but you can still tell that it is Taylor because the lyrics and phrasing are original.


If you really think KELLY CLARKSON writes musical melodies with her voice then you are ****ing crazy. Give me some receipts, and she will shoot straight to number one on my all- time musicians list . This fantasy of Kelly being a great songwriter is ridiculous