[Scepter]

[manwhore]

SMASH of the MILLENIUM

[KangBey]

Originally posted by vuelve88

It still peaked higher than every "4" single without a single performance. Keep it cute.

Not you having to go back in time 3yrs ago. Sis join us in the 2014 era, where Beyonce's album has sold 3 million copies WW in 2 months and already has a top 3 hit. And CRTFY can't crack the top 10, even with help from jingles artist Rih. Yes, lets keep it all the way cute.

[vuelve88]

Originally posted by KangBey

Not you having to go back in time 3yrs ago. Sis join us in the 2014 era, where Beyonce's album has sold 3 million copies WW in 2 months and already has a top 3 hit. And CRTFY can't crack the top 10, even with help from jingles artist Rih. Yes, lets keep it all the way cute.

She hasn't even performed the song. That means no Oprah performance, no Billboard Music Awards. Nothing.

I'm just saying, if you want to throw around words like "big ol flop" when talking about "Can't Remember To Forget You", you better be fair enough to refer to all of those singles in the same manner, but you probably won't.

[PrettyHurts]

underperformance imo
very forgettable and lackluster song

[Lorelei]

Why do you have to turn everything into a stupid stanwar? Song is bad therefore Rihannas name wouldnt save it anyway, im looking forward to her next singles and congrats to Beyonce for selling 3M albums WW but seriously stop it. The thread is about CRTFY.

[PrettyHurts]

Originally posted by Lorelei

Why do you have to turn everything into a stupid stanwar? Song is bad therefore Rihannas name wouldnt save it anyway, im looking forward to her next singles and congrats to Beyonce for selling 3M albums WW but seriously stop it. The thread is about CRTFY.

mte
i fail to see how this thread has anything to do with bey.......

[swissman]

Originally posted by vuelve88

She hasn't even performed the song. That means no Oprah performance, no Billboard Music Awards. Nothing.

I'm just saying, if you want to throw around words like "big ol flop" when talking about "Can't Remember To Forget You", you better be fair enough to refer to all of those singles in the same manner, but you probably won't.

In today's climate a hit / controversial video can do more for your song than an Oprah performance though.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Moderate hit for sure.

[vuelve88]

Originally posted by swissman

In today's climate a hit / controversial video can do more for your song than an Oprah performance though.

It's definitely helped the song, but let's give Shakira time to perform the song at least once before making definitive claims about it being a flop.

[swissman]

Originally posted by vuelve88

It's definitely helped the song, but let's give Shakira time to perform the song at least once before making definitive claims about it being a flop.

I agree.

I think the first post in the thread nailed it. It's neither a flop nor a hit.

[Bie]

A flop

You have Rihanna on your song but it can't go even top 10 with streaming, it's a huge flop.

[D_Man3379]

underperformance. It's just not catchy.

[Safe&Sound]

It peaked at #4 iTunes WW chart
pretty impressive and the video really has impact to its chart performance
I'd say moderate hit-hit, because I believe it will reach platinum someday

[Giancor]

Ww hit.

[Azealia Banks]

Flop :/

[KangBey]

Originally posted by Lorelei

Why do you have to turn everything into a stupid stanwar? Song is bad therefore Rihannas name wouldnt save it anyway, im looking forward to her next singles and congrats to Beyonce for selling 3M albums WW but seriously stop it. The thread is about CRTFY.

Girl bye, tell that to the Shakira stan who first brought up Bey's name.

Originally posted by vuelve88

She hasn't even performed the song. That means no Oprah performance, no Billboard Music Awards. Nothing.

I'm just saying, if you want to throw around words like "big ol flop" when talking about "Can't Remember To Forget You", you better be fair enough to refer to all of those singles in the same manner, but you probably won't.

This is a new era boo, 2014 and you are dancing around this song being a flop. Even with the help of jingles success artist Rih. I'm just answering the op's question and the poll shows majority considers this song a flop. Not sure why you are harping and pressed about my reply, but you can stay mad.

[ChrisRTW]

Flop

[Tena]

People seriously think a performance will help?

[vuelve88]

Originally posted by KangBey

Girl bye, tell that to the Shakira stan who first brought up Bey's name.



This is a new era boo, 2014 and you are dancing around this song being a flop. Even with the help of jingles success artist Rih. I'm just answering the op's question and the poll shows majority considers this song a flop. Not sure why you are harping and pressed about my reply, but you can stay mad.

K. Let's hope she doesn't get 5+ consecutive "big ol flop"s then.

She still has at least 4 more opportunities to redeem herself.