Quote:
Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant
But isn't "I prefer her to them" preference, as you said?
If you're going to compare their artistry there are solid arguments to be made (although they're obviously always influenced by subjectivity, that is true) - otherwise what's the point of criticism at all?
|
To facilitate understanding and foster discussion that allows people to potentially see things from a different perspective they might not have otherwise, which ultimately allows us to better understand each other and the world in which we live.
Obviously, the more convincing/thought-out argument you make the more prone others will be to understand and appreciate your judgment whether or not they necessarily identify with it themselves, but I don't think you have to be able to articulate a logical basis for your reaction.
I think it's generally understood when it comes to art that any statement which evaluates a piece of work as "good"/"bad" or "better"/"worse in comparison to others simply constitutes a personal value judgement which can't be right or wrong. I'd say criticism seeks to rationalize our visceral reaction, and while the process is beneficial that should be kept in mind.
