[Phre$h]

She is very succsessful but nobody really cares about her tbh so no.

[nabee]

she is a very good contender, but for me she's always under the radar.
Well a silent legend could be

[dfantasy]

Originally posted by atrlster

1.) She didn't do it though
2.) It was The Voice Australia not The Voice.
3.) The residency is seen as a negative thing for Britney...so why would you want to brag about that

My point is ATRLers always says baseless, ridiculous comments like 'no one checks for her' 'she has no impact' but in reality she was always asked first by all the moguls in the industry - imagine if she did all those things. Though I'm glad she didn't do the Kiss because look how that turned out for Aguilera.

3) Residency is a negative thing for Britney because she's a washed up popstar who sucks. P!nk would kill it, like she did at her TTAL tour.

[D.D.D.]

Originally posted by loveintothelight

there's a bigger chance that she has a penis

omg

[Pandora30012]

She had some big hits last year. But besides those hits i never realy hear anything about her

[alrightsir]

Let's be clear here: ATRL doesn't care about P!nk. Some of it admits she's great but she will be never in the center of the attention because the music taste of ATRL (or I could say gays). She's not in the media 24/7, doesn't have scandals and whatsoever, doesn't "serve" and she's not a diva. But the truth is undeniable, the GP loves her and she has a wide-scale of fans, straight to gay, young to old. She can do what others only dream about: leave for 1-2 years and come back slaying again.

[Underdogs]

Hmmm considering the amount of success, respect & influence she has; she's already a legend. Popularity has absolutely nothing to do with it.

EDIT: She gets recurrent airplay, too!

[superben]

I don't think so.

She'll be an icon, though.

Originally posted by loveintothelight

there's a bigger chance that she has a penis

I feel bad for laughing

[nihility]

Originally posted by loveintothelight

there's a bigger chance that she has a penis

[ToxicKiss92]

she alredy is a legend. Critics and GP love her and let's not forget who's the queen of Australia.

[Phoenixx]

She already is a Legend. What kinda flop question?

[Liafen]

Originally posted by alrightsir

Let's be clear here: ATRL doesn't care about P!nk. Some of it admits she's great but she will be never in the center of the attention because the music taste of ATRL (or I could say gays). She's not in the media 24/7, doesn't have scandals and whatsoever, doesn't "serve" and she's not a diva. But the truth is undeniable, the GP loves her and she has a wide-scale of fans, straight to gay, young to old. She can do what others only dream about: leave for 1-2 years and come back slaying again.

/endthread

Not at some of you she doesn't take risks and doesn't change. Yeah, sure, M!ssundaztood was R&B like Can't Take Me Home. (No, it wasn't.) And Try This was pop-rock like M!ss. (No, it wasn't.) And she's just got successful? A 4 million debut and a 13 million follow-up isn't that successful, I guess.

Anyway, she's not at legend status. Yet.

[bluth]

She'll be continually successful if she sticks to her 'knows-what's-good' formula but real legends take risks or push the boat out, at least. I admit though that her Glitter in the Air performance was what could be a legendary moment.

[T.C]

Originally posted by bluth

She'll be continually successful if she sticks to her 'knows-what's-good' formula but real legends take risks or push the boat out, at least. I admit though that her Glitter in the Air performance was what could be a legendary moment.

Good post bluth

[P!nkInside]

P!nk was destined to be a legend ever since her debut. She broke the industry's mold and redefined what a popstar is supposed to act & look like.

And your trend hopping faves aren't risk takers lol Just because they sing whatever's popular does not mean it's a positive thing. P!nk has a signature, almost instantly recognizable sound and she comes and slays regardless of what the current trend is.

Two years ago, ATRL was convinced Britney and Gaga were going to be legends and look at them, complete jokes. LOL

[musicfan09]

Of course
But the first three posts

[Phil]

I love Pink, but if she's not relevant today, she will never be

[AnginaWilliams]

She'll be a legend in her own right like a Sade or George Michael. She'll be able to sell out arenas for the rest of her life since her talent and her success are not dependent on fickle pop music trends.

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by Phil

I love Pink, but if she's not relevant today, she will never be

Lady Gaga Nelly Furtado Adam Lambert Ashley Tisdale

[TheO™]

Originally posted by Katie

P!nk is so done wrong. She's got a catalog of hits, killer tours, and a video collection to die for. Yet for some reason, she's never included next to her peers.

Baybe because she is above and beyond many of them.