Goodbye Career didn't sell Half of 4 and Avril battled Britney through out 2011 for the title of "Lowest tier girl" of all the pop girls .
Pink has outlasted her and outside of Asia whatever relevance she did have is forgotten much like most of her catalogue.
Using album sales from back when albums sold doesn't erase the fact that Avril is nothing now and everyone is stomping on her while nobody cares.
Glitter was hyped up by Mariah like her personal project because she had little control over her career prior to Rainbow (the album before Glitter) and the singles from the album and the album itself flopped and her label betrayed her, bought out her contract and basically left her on the street to fend for herself. All throughout the era Mariah was posting weird, self defensive things on her website much like Madame GayGay is doing now.
Debatable. For Maraiah standards maybe. Still commercially Glitter (album) did way better that FartFlop.
Tho Loverboy was her first lead single to not reach #1 peaking stalling at #2 tragic times for the biggest pop star on the planet.
Who cares about #1s? Telephone made IFPI, way more important. But overall IIWB is more remembered so yeah. Bey's most remembered song on a global scale is probably Halo.
Anyone here watch Braxton Family Values? Lipton? OMG Towanda is so jealous at Tamar for being super successful, it's so obvious by now. That birthday episode was an embarrassing mess.
Tamar is so ****ing extra but Towanda is hella bitter!!! and for what thats her lil sis she should be proud of her
Swinefest ****ing slayed. she should have dumped MJH/Donatella/Dope & kept those ambient interludes
I only used ARTPOP (the LIVE sing) and Jewel and Drugs (before she changed it. and killed DJWS breakdown :lipton)
Honestly, I can't even remember the other songs she performed. I just remember not liking them and them being all so horrible.
Gaga fell for Beyonces tricks. She always sucks the dick of the most popular artists for features. Sean Paul, Shakira, Lady Gaga, and the numerous of first singles with her husband
tragic times for the biggest pop star on the planet. 
