[ScottyGaga]

Originally posted by Kkamjong

And here I thought I had seen it all

We're going to ignore single sales, album sales, media, etc. and talk use an atrl poll to determine who the public likes

This poll isn't asking who the public like, it's asking who makes the best music. Selling more does not mean the music is better.

[Ben.M.]

Originally posted by gagakyle

thats what i thought... isnt it bed time now sis

[BadBitches]

Originally posted by Alchemist

How about the one who released a song 'Ur So Gay' and I Kissed a Girl to grab attention for her album

Drag ha by ha cotton candy wig

[Cupcake.]

Originally posted by Temple

You listen to 1D tho

Their lyrics make sense and are relatable. And just like Katy they've progressed with each album and they dont sound nothing like each other except the singles.
Your point?

[johnsuxx]

Originally posted by DanceForYou

Death @ Katy stans calling I Kissed a Girl risky. Another Dr. Luke production. A beautiful girl with big **** talking about kissing girls...omg so controversial. We all know it's way more acceptable for an attractive female to sing about stuff like that. It' wasn't taboo at all to anyone besides the extremely sheltered and close minded religious freaks of the world.

It was actually very controversial for 2008 and it's a shock that radio picked it up!

Also, why bash "generic" Dr Luke when Gaga worked with another "generic" producer, RedOne, for 3 albums?

[KangBey]

Gaga by miles.

[DanceForYou]

Originally posted by johnsuxx

It was actually very controversial for 2008 and it's a shock that radio picked it up!

Also, why bash "generic" Dr Luke when Gaga worked with another "generic" producer, RedOne, for 3 albums?

I never called The Fame risky while ya'll are saying IKAG was.

[Beatfreak]

I feel like Katy vs Gaga has become the new Britney vs Xtina....

Maybe they should do a VMA kiss with Britney

[Matthew]

Paparazzi, Bad Romance, Dance in the Dark, Marry the Night, Government Hooker, Heavy Metal Lover, Bloody Mary, The Edge of Glory, Scheibe, ARTPOP, Do What U Want, G.U.Y. & Gypsy >>>>>>>>> Anything Katy has done (except for E.T., Legendary Lovers & The One That Got Away).

[Kinuotose]

SOME OF Y'ALL HYPOCRITES

[KatyCat007]

Katy

[Azealia Banks]

Originally posted by Cupcake.

Their lyrics make sense and are relatable. And just like Katy they've progressed with each album and they dont sound nothing like each other except the singles.
Your point?

yeah relatable to 12 year old girls

[rihbeyhybrid]

I don't like Katy's music so.....Gaga

[gagakyle]

Originally posted by johnsuxx

It was actually very controversial for 2008 and it's a shock that radio picked it up!

Also, why bash "generic" Dr Luke when Gaga worked with another "generic" producer, RedOne, for 3 albums?

omg

[400Lux]

Originally posted by johnsuxx

It was actually very controversial for 2008 and it's a shock that radio picked it up!

Also, why bash "generic" Dr Luke when Gaga worked with another "generic" producer, RedOne, for 3 albums?

Because she managed to make critically acclaimed music from that work.
RedOne is only generic when he works with other singers.

[Kkamjong]

Originally posted by DanceForYou

You can get a sense of someone's intelligence by listening to them speak. Katy has never captivated me watching any interview of hers. She seems very vapid and she never seems to have anything of depth to say. I'm not deluded by saying Gaga is an intelligent woman. Would you disagree with my statement?

All Gaga has done is prove to the world she is a pretentious musician who is one of the biggest, if not the biggest, megalomaniac to ever exist.

I watched her interviews in "The Fame" era. They did not give me the feel she was "intelligent" since you want to say go based off speech and she only got pretentious when her fame spiked.

All she ever does is talk about gays, sex, and herself. Nothing amazing about that

[mariomania]

Gaga by far.

[Futuristic Lover]

Oh at monsters acting like her music is some out of this world ****. Just cause some of her music is trash doesn't make it risky

[Temple]

Originally posted by Cupcake.

Their lyrics make sense and are relatable. And just like Katy they've progressed with each album and they dont sound nothing like each other except the singles.
Your point?

[Emcee]

The arrogance that many of the Gaga fans here possess. Check yourself cause that haughty attitude from Gaga and her monsters is what's turning off many ears from her music.

That said, I love the discographies of both.