[viperial]

does madonna play the piano? serious question!

[Buddy!]

As a whole, they are both very talented. (can't Madonna play the guitar?) Hard to say, but based on the question im going to say Gaga.

[like2throw]

Originally posted by bijonse

Madonna. Gaga has more talent in her pinky than Madonna has in her body but Madonna has a good ear for music theres a reason shes been around for like 30 years

that doesnt make her a better musician, she just chooses her material better

the thing is though, I believe Madonna has a hand in the craft of her writing, if im not mistaken? (maybe someone could clarify this). So Im choosing her anyways.

[Whorehaus of Gaga]

Makes a lot of sense to compare material from a career of 30 years to material from 5 years. No idea tbh but voted for Gaga because when you sit her by a piano and she sings one of her songs... well... I don't think Madonna can compete.

[Almighty Gaga]

Lol. Gaga definitely.

[6 Apple St]

Performer: Madonna
Vocals: Lady Gaga
Music: tie
Imo Gaga

[madonnas]

Originally posted by viperial

does madonna play the piano? serious question!

No she doesn't. She plays guitar though.

[Nialler]

Madonna, she's got such a diverse discography in terms of bringing together new sounds and constantly going in the new direction whilst still being very successful that everyone can forgive her tour album MDNE

edit: the fact that Gaga plays piano and Madge guitar doesn't make the first one superior what kind of logic

[BlueTimberwolf]

Gaga is a classically trained pianist. Madonna can barely strum a guitar

[Donquizote]

Madonna. Her songwriting is better.

[DitaBoy12]

Madonna.

[Britboyuk]

Originally posted by viperial

does madonna play the piano? serious question!

No she doesn't

[DitaBoy12]

Originally posted by viperial

does madonna play the piano? serious question!

No but she plays the guitar.

[Buddy!]

Originally posted by Nialler

Madonna, she's got such a diverse discography in terms of bringing together new sounds and constantly going in the new direction whilst still being very successful that everyone can forgive her tour album MDNE

Well obviously her discography will be more diverse, she's been around for 30 years. You can say the same with Gaga as well. BTW, and The Fame have two different sounds. Atleast imo.

[Lord Blackout]

Originally posted by bijonse

Madonna. Gaga has more talent in her pinky than Madonna has in her body but Madonna has a good ear for music theres a reason shes been around for like 30 years

Lmao Gaga is not that talented.

[MCBeth]

Better Vocalist: Gaga
Better Dancer: Madonna
Better songwriter/producer: Madonna has better material but I feel like Lady Gaga has more involvement in the craft of her music than Madge but regardless, Madonna.
Better Performer: Madonna
Extra: Gaga plays the piano + Madonna plays the guitar

Overall: Madonna

[Melquiades]

Gaga is an average piano player but I suppose she knows some of music theory so it's gotta be her.

[Noriega]

Love me some Gaga but I will replay Bedtime Stories for an eternity. My fav Madonna album.

[HolyKatyPerry]

[Badger]

Gaga is in terms of talent, but Madonna is the better musician in terms of creating material