[UpAllNight]

Taylor in the top 10 .
They know the tea.

[Sombra]

No Britney?

[Retro]

Decent list, but it's missing some people.

[izzy]

gurl bye,Janet shuld be in top 5

[Melquiades]

That top 4 is a disgrace.

[Alejandrawrrr]

Mariah should be top 5, she constantly gets disrespected by music critics and lists like these

The only major flub on this list is Celine. If it's based on voice/talent, she's easily top 10. If it's based on record sales she's, what, top 3? Zero logic behind her being number 28.

[superben]

What kinda flop list?

Madonna is lower than Beyonce?

Cher is not even top 20 and Celine is outside top 25??

[El Chiko Kevo]

This was written by an idiot!!

Flop list!!!!

[El Chiko Kevo]

#1 should be Madonna!

Katy should NOT be on the list ! Rihanna is too high! Pink is too high! beyond is before Madonna

[Mr. Martin]

But this is a mess, I agree Tina Turner and Aretha Franklin are more important for music than Madonna, but Whitney is not. And btw the list does not include Björk or Janis Joplin, who played a more important role in music than many others I see in this list.

[Scuba_Dive]

Originally posted by LP54

30. Karen Carpenter
26. Lady Gaga
25. Pat Benatar
24. Shania Twain
23. Cher
19. Cyndi Lauper
16. Donna Summer
13. Dolly Parton
12. Christina Aguilera
11. Janet Jackson
10. Blondie
9. Taylor Swift
6. Diana Ross

These are the best ones, esp the criminally underrated Karen Carpenter!

[Citrus]

Originally posted by Ashrock

Do it by yourself

Slay Taylor !!! the youngest winner of AOTY deserves to be top 10

Youngest winner in the weakest year is not nearly as big an accomplishment as the things that Cher has done. Talk to me in 4 decades and we'll see if Taylor has a fraction of what Cher does now. Don't feel bad, it's not just Taylor's inclusion that's a slap in the face of decency. It's Katy's and Rihanna's, too. Cher is Cher for god's sake. Terrible start to the new year.

[.aR]

Not at Beyonce beating out all the legends

[Chill Bill]

WTF? No Janis Joplin, Joni Mitchell, Barbra Streisand, Carole King, Joan Jett or Tracy Chapman?

[Mikeymoonshine]

This list is ridiculous.

Why is Katy above Adele, Gaga, Celine Dion, Karen Carpenter and Cher?

Why is Rihanna so high? Why is T swift at 9? She's been massive recently but she's certainly not the ninth greatest woman in music.

Tbh I think allot of people are only on this list because they are current. Most of them have a way to go before becoming as Iconic as people like Blondie, Tina, Madge ect.

Even Gaga hasn't done that.

[Beyy]

Of all time? Well done Bey, greater than Madonna!

[Cristhian]

Where's Janis Joplin?

[Mikeymoonshine]

Why isn't Kate Bush on the list?

[avrilisepic]

Avril Lavigne, Janis Joplin, Joan Jett & Loretta Lynn should have been on the list though...

[Chill Bill]

Originally posted by Mikeymoonshine

This list is ridiculous.

Why is Katy above Adele, Gaga, Celine Dion, Karen Carpenter and Cher?

Why is Rihanna so high? Why is T swift at 9? She's been massive recently but she's certainly not the ninth greatest woman in music.

Tbh I think allot of people are only on this list because they are current. Most of them have a way to go before becoming as Iconic as people like Blondie, Tina, Madge ect.

Even Gaga hasn't done that.

Blondie's the name of the band, silly goose. You're thinking of Debbie Harry.