[Relampago.]

Before y'all blow up on me, I am a huge fan of both these wonderful ladies.

Now, I chose Rihanna specifically because I believe with current pop girls, none of them have a song as iconic as Umbrella, which is likely Rihanna's most iconic song. Except for Beyonce.

Whenever Umbrella comes on, people all say "oh I love this song!" then sing the "eh, eh, eh" part. But when Single Ladies come on, people start doing the dance and sing a very large part of the song. This is what I've seen in my personal experiences in real life and on TV/the internet.

So, is Single Ladies more iconic than any Rihanna song?

[Ger-55]

No

[Relampago.]

Poll added.

[Honey]

Yes.

[jomarr]

Even Hate that I Love You is more iconic than that song

[Twixxted]

No

[Guero]

Obviously, Rihanna only has Umbrella, which isn't even that memorable tbh.

[Ascension]

Mixed: In the US -- I think so; globally, no.

[Bloo]

Rihanna doesn't really have that many memorable songs, to be honest.

[Reza]

we found love, umbrella, please don't stop the music. diamonds and pon de replay say hi!

[LONGWAY2GO.]

Single Ladies isn't even iconic, lol

[BabyCantYouSee]

Definitely. Well atleast here in Canada, I think it is. Rihanna is still a more global celebrity.

[BPD]

Originally posted by Relampago.

Before y'all blow up on me, I am a huge fan of both these wonderful ladies.

Now, I chose Rihanna specifically because I believe with current pop girls, none of them have a song as iconic as Umbrella, which is likely Rihanna's most iconic song. Except for Beyonce.

Whenever Umbrella comes on, people all say "oh I love this song!" then sing the "eh, eh, eh" part. But when Single Ladies come on, people start doing the dance and sing a very large part of the song. This is what I've seen in my personal experiences in real life and on TV/the internet.

So, is Single Ladies more iconic than any Rihanna song?

Ummm Beautiful by Christina Aguilera says HELLO

[GlitterfiedCyrus]

Well the song isn't iconic, it's the video.
But no I don't think it is.

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

"HI" said Poker Face and Bad Romance

[Guero]

Originally posted by duybeeGAshantiGA

"HI" said Poker Face and Bad Romance

What does this have to do with Gaga?

[TheOnlyOne]

Not when Single Ladies already sounds more dated than even SOS.

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

Originally posted by Guero

What does this have to do with Gaga?

why didnt u ask the Xtina stan who said Beautiful tho

[Heartbeat Song]

yes. single ladies is more iconic than anything Rih has or will do.

[Mike91]

Yes.