I suspect, as with everything Gaga does, her album reviews will be mixed. All will be enthusiastically positive or negative, though, as opposed to the general "meh" reaction Katy got.
A strong reaction but you will feel like critics actually wanted to listen to and review the album as opposed to feeling like it was just part of the job (as with Prism). But yes the general backlash she's seen the past few years will come into play.