[Ady.]

Originally posted by Genocide

That post is excluding US sales to represent how much each of their albums have sold outside of the states. I didn't add any sales from the US in those figures

I obviously saw that. I gave you the numbers outside US.

[rbautz]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

But Back to Black was released the same time as Back to Basics only it actually struck big and Amy had already released Frank three years before. The whole throwback blue-eyed soul trend that has primarily come from UK obviously has way more to do with Amy than Xtina. If anything, Legend X has usually been behind the curve, not ahead of it.

Joss Stone became also famous at the time of Frank.

But who started this in England?

My bet is Propellerheads with Shirley Bassey , it was a huge hit in 1997. They were(Joss, Amy, Duffy, Adele etc.) all about 10-15 years old at this time, I'm sure they were impressed.

[rihannafan]

AGLM: 2M
MOTS: 1M
GGGB: 6M
Rated R: 2.5M
Loud: 5M
TTT: 2.5M
Unapologetic: 2.5M

Corrected numbers. The average is higher than 3 despite the more frequent releases.

[Genocide]

Rihanna:
20.5M/7 = 2.92M

she still loses either way. And I was using the your figures, too .

edit: let me re-add

[Clump]

Originally posted by Nicole

Twilight fans.

But go Perri. Music's most relevant Christina.

It's a cute song. I'd play it at my over-the-top cliche gay wedding if this song didn't exist.

[Shinning]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

What did you think of Sammi's meltdown?

Understandable
I'm just concentrating on Gaga nowadays. At least she's doing something and keeping it exciting. I love the tour but it's not exactly the same as having new music out. I'll keep waiting though. What else can I do?

[Kworb]

Originally posted by Halien4Life

The best concert DVD of all time

[Lipton]

Fefe

[Ady.]

Originally posted by Shinning

At the end, even with all her #1's and records sold Rihanna won't ever be anything other than the girl that got beat up by Chris Brown. No respect, no acclaim, no interest ever.
Never an icon, never a legend, always an untalented joke.

.

...said no one ever, except delusional Beyonce fans.

Billboard's All-Time list:

#24 We Found Love

Beyonce N/C

[Lipton]

I need a new ablum

[rihannafan]

Originally posted by Shinning

Ugh this discussion is so stale and since Beyonce refuses to release ha album I don't even feel like talking about the same old album sales

nnnn ok as you wish

@genocide, the sum is 21.5 not 20.5.

[RudeBoyy]

Originally posted by Genocide

Beyonce's album sales outside of the us:

DIL: 4M
B'day: 3M
IASF: 4M
4: 1M~2M

Total: 13M

Rihanna:
AGLM: <1M
MOTS: <1M
GGGB: 6M
Rated R: 1M-2M
Loud: 5M
TTT: 2M
Unapologetic: 2M

Total: 19M

Average:
Bey: 13/4 = 3.25M
Rihanna: 19/7 = 2.7M

But I thought she was local?

Rihanna's outside the U.s sales:
MOTS: 900k
AGLM: 2.3 million
GGGB: 7.2 million
Rated R: 3 million
Loud: 4.3 million
Talk That Talk: 2.3 million
Unapologetic: 2.2 million (and is still selling well)

22.3 million.

22.3/7 = 3.12 outside the U.s per album.

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by rihannafan

You con't compare like that. Beyonce did not start from scratch like Rihanna did, she a previous DC career to fall back on.

Destiny's Child: 3 million
Music Of The Sun: 2.5 million

The Writing's On The Wall: 14 million
A Girl Like Me: 3 million

Survivor - 10 million
GGGB: 8 million

Destiny Fulfilled: 6 million
Rated R: 3 million

DIL: 9 million
Loud: 6 million

B'Day: 6.5 million
TTT: 3 million

IASF: 7 million
Unapologetic: 3.5 million

Beyonce: 60 million
Rihanna: 29 million

Again, where is the argument?

[Lipton]

DON'T LET IT GO TO YOUR HEAD

[Shinning]

It keeps throwing numbers at me like it matters to the discussion
Your fave will end up a Janet/Paula Abdul mess in the end. It's in her destiny.

[Cap10Planet]

Ain't nothin' better
We beat the odds together
I'm glad we didn't listen
Look at what we would be missin'

They said, "I bet they'll never make it"
But just look at us holding on
We're still together still going strong

[Lipton]

Fefe is the black Avril. She would have made it if she had been white.

[Remixed]

The decline in quality

[Genocide]

Where's the receipts for AGLM and Rated R's sales (outside of the US)? I'll budge with Rated R, but AGLM selling 2M out the states seems too much of a reach for me

[2AM]

Originally posted by satellites.™

Music Of The Sun: 2.5 million

Rated R: 3.5 million

Givin em' too much.
MOTS has sold 1.5M at MOST.
Rated R has barely reached 3M if that.