Girl these are antics and vocal show offs. Show me where gaga does not have her piano, stands and sings a ballad in it's entirety and still moves a live audience.
Girl these are antics and vocal show offs. Show me where gaga does not have her piano, stands and sings a ballad in it's entirety and still moves a live audience.
you're still at it!
why can't she use a piano? why does she have to stand and sing? your attitude toward gaga is very well-known on here but i'm amused that you're trying so hard in a losing battle.
Girl these are antics and vocal show offs. Show me where gaga does not have her piano, stands and sings a ballad in it's entirety and still moves a live audience.
You OBVIOUSLY did not watch the second video
she is clearly not sitting at a piano
You all are missing what I'm trying to say. IDC what anybody says. when gaga sings a ballad, it's not authentic. point blank period. Every time rihanna sings a ballad, whether bad vocally or not, it's AUTHENTIC. she connects with her audience. that's what make's her better at ballads live.
So, that's your opinion then? You don't see Gaga's (ballad) performances as authentic, whereas Rihanna's are. I don't disagree with you; I find Rihanna's ability to emote as one of her (few) performing strengths that make her relatable, whereas Gaga's virtuosity and grandeur can sometimes place a barrier between her and her audience.
That being said, just because Gaga's sense of theatricality and performance can sometimes dull the edge of an emotionally-charged performance doesn't mean that she is incapable of it - the videos posted of her performing Speechless, Marry the Night, Edge of Glory and even the rousing You & I during the Monster Ball show prove otherwise.
why can't she use a piano? why does she have to stand and sing? your attitude toward gaga is very well-known on here but i'm amused that you're trying so hard in a losing battle.
Laugh at me all you want, Point still stands, I never feel anything when I watch gaga sing a ballad. sorry. rihanna to me will always be a better live performer of ballads than gaga.
Clearly, you misunderstood what it means to have an opinion. It can't be fact or fiction. It's an opinion.
And I'm getting dragged? Okay, whatever who cares. my opinion still stands.
Then why are you saying that she has no performances where she moved an audience? If you're saying it's an opinion, you shouldn't even be arguing about it
Laugh at me all you want, Point still stands, I never feel anything when I watch gaga sing a ballad. sorry. rihanna to me will always be a better live performer of ballads than gaga.
but you're vehemently anti-gaga in almost everything you post on here, so of course you would think that way. there are obviously gaga stans that are the same way, but at least realize you have your stan glasses on a bit
So, that's your opinion then? You don't see Gaga's (ballad) performances as authentic, whereas Rihanna's are. I don't disagree with you; I find Rihanna's ability to emote as one of her (few) performing strengths that make her relatable, whereas Gaga's virtuosity and grandeur can sometimes place a barrier between her and her audience.
That being said, just because Gaga's sense of theatricality and performance can sometimes dull the edge of an emotionally-charged performance doesn't mean that she is incapable of it - the videos posted of her performing Speechless, Marry the Night, Edge of Glory and even the rousing You & I performances of the Monster Ball show prove otherwise.
Don't get me wrong. Those are exceptional vocally. I forgot to mention that. I give credit where credit is due. but to me, they aren't moving. I just don't believe her. and that's just ME.
but you're vehemently anti-gaga in almost everything you post on here, so of course you would think that way. there are obviously gaga stans that are the same way, but at least realize you have your stan glasses on a bit
LOL, maybe you missed the part where I said gaga was better at rihanna in other areas? I never said rihanna was this big exceptional performer. She's still improving. you see what you want to see in my posts. I'm only trying to argue one point. If you don't agree, fine. But dont make this out to be me being a gaga hater. clearly that's not the case....
This is the only place where I have ever heard someone actually say Rihanna MOVES people with her performances.
In the real world, this is not the case. Rihanna is an average singer, at best, with good looks. That's all.
Exactly. She used to be below average performance wise. She just recently moved on up to average. Her performances for the Unapologetic era promo run were good because she was standing in one spot not moving for the songs since they were ballads (Diamonds & Stay.) If her lead was an uptempo like it was for WFL and Only Girl, then she would still be sounding a mess.
