Here are my comments for all of you, except Matthew since I already gave him my comments.
Daniel - Your flow, for me, was the best out of all. You gave a theme of the different sides to Rihanna and made a pretty nice progression of the sides. However your album title, wasn't very Rihanna. I was also confused with it because I was given to names of your album. Some of your song choices were a bit weird for the sides. Like Question Existing as Rihanna's ****ty side. No, no no no. That is her vulnerable side, not ****ty.
Hugamari - You tried to give a back story to your album, but it made me laugh. Your album title was good, I could see Ke$ha using it. Your choice of songs were okay, too many songs from Warrior. There are plenty of great tracks from Cannibal and Animal to even it out. Your flow was really weak to me though. It was just everywhere and for someone like Ke$ha, starting with a ballad is a NO!
Nathan - Overall, it was okay. Out of the three criteria, your choice of songs were one of the best. However I docked a few points because I didn't see many songs from All I Ever Wanted and Thankful. Your album title didn't scream Kelly for me, but I understood why you chose it. It went with the flow of the album which was very midtempo ballad-y. You started off with a ballad, which for someone like Kelly, just isn't right. Should have started with something like Let Me Down or Gone or Addicted, something heavy and rock to give that Kelly-esque vibe.
Sinny - Honestly the best of all them. Not because you had the most tracks, but because you made it all work. The title was the best, very Rihanna. You had a great selection of her unreleased gems. You gave variety of genres, gave a nice space between the uptempos, midtempos, and the ballads. The beats worked with the flow and just really worked. It could have been a little better, a few songs could have been taken out. Overall, well done.
Collin - Maybe you shouldn't have let Jeremy do your work for you. Screwed you over. Let's start with the album title. Very unoriginal, VERY. Yes, it is predictable and could be a title, but it's the title of her book so it's already being used. Your choice of songs could have been WAY better. It was basically half of Warrior and a forth of Animal. Where are the songs from Cannibal like Cannibal, Grow a Pear, The Harold Song? Could have a better songs. Now a bit of positive news, the flow was pretty good. You started out uptempo and fun, kept it uptempo like an actual Ke$ha album, had some of her great slower songs in there, some good placements.
*** Probably some bad grammar, but I don't give a **** 