[Chileno]

Originally posted by LDYGG

Elton John, Cher, Sting, Bono, Patti Labelle, Gene Simmons, and a plethora of other actual musical icons disagree.

Originally posted by fabbriche

He's right. Only the Little Monsters think Gaga is an icon.

[Jewfro]

Ne-Yo

[Paparazzo]

Originally posted by Amaru

Ne Yo said this?! Didn't he write Just Dance?

No that was Akon!

[Riverwide]

The irony of Ne-Yo of all people saying that GaGa isn't an icon.

It's hilarious!

[BlazingLovatic]

I think she will be an icon according to her little(?) monsters but she's faded among the GP rapidly throughout the past era so I don't think she'll be an icon in 10 years for her music, but she could be for her style

[NEUTRON]

I'm not understanding how anyone in this thread can read off the definition of Icon and not see a picture of Lady GaGa. It's impossible.

[Riverwide]

Originally posted by Paparazzo

It's like Katy Perry saying Beyonce cannot sing.

Exactly.

[jayyyxtee]

Originally posted by heavymetal0verr

Madonna fans are bothered by Lady Gaga's success, and the fact that their fave can no longer do in interview without her younger successor's name being bought up evidently upsets them

clock dem sis

[IsidoraMarí]

Monsters acting like Ne-Yo isn't the Babyface/Smokey Robinson of our generation.!!

Originally posted by NEUTRON

I'm not understanding how anyone in this thread can read off the definition of Icon and not see a picture of Lady GaGa. It's impossible.

See I label Icons as people like Aretha Franklin, MJ, Janet, Madonna, Elvis.

People who's work has stood the test of time.

So I think he's saying she's not gonna be relevant for more than 10 years.

[Riverwide]

Originally posted by DimmiFenty

Monsters acting like Ne-Yo isn't the Babyface/Smokey Robinson of our generation.!!

You're kidding, right?

99.99% of the population haven't even heard of Ne-Yo and his cheap, generic, disposable songs. GaGa is the most famous person on the planet, with a dozen memorable worldwide hits.

[IsidoraMarí]

Originally posted by Riverwide

You're kidding, right?

99.99% of the population haven't even heard of Ne-Yo and his cheap, generic, disposable songs. GaGa is the most famous person on the planet, with a dozen memorable worldwide hits.

Please name a dozen.

[Sláy]

She's as close as you can get. And no one is an icon within 4 career years neyo.

[Sláy]

Originally posted by DimmiFenty

Monsters acting like Ne-Yo isn't the Babyface/Smokey Robinson of our generation.!!




See I label Icons as people like Aretha Franklin, MJ, Janet, Madonna, Elvis.

People who's work has stood the test of time.

they are legends not icons. Difference.

[KESTER]

Ne-yo is in the pits with Pitbull and Flo-Rida

[IsidoraMarí]

Originally posted by Sláy

they are legends not icons. Difference.

I view it differently, people can have Iconic moments, but when they become National Treasures they are Icons.

Like Beyonce is a Legend to me but not an Icon. Yet.

[jayyyxtee]

Originally posted by Amaru

Ne Yo said this?! Didn't he write Just Dance?

SIS WHAT?!?!?!??!

[jayyyxtee]

Originally posted by Paparazzo

No that was Akon!

[Cap10Planet]

[Riverwide]

Originally posted by DimmiFenty

Please name a dozen.

Well I can name ELEVEN that are genuine worldwide hits...

Just Dance
Pokerface
LoveGame
Paparazzi
Bad Romance
Telephone
Alejandro
Born This Way
Judas
The Edge of Glory
You & I

[HausOfA-M]

Originally posted by Riverwide

Well I can name ELEVEN that are genuine worldwide hits...

Just Dance
Pokerface
LoveGame
Paparazzi
Bad Romance
Telephone
Alejandro
Born This Way
Judas
The Edge of Glory
You & I

Still a lot.