[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by Rentboy

requiring FACTS is not being pressed.

I don't get why they can't respect other people's criticisms.

[BlondeAmbitionxX]

Originally posted by Rentboy

Is that really what matters to you? Is that why you stan for a music artist?

sorry, I find that a bit depressing. It should be all about the music and their artistic output. Not these sideline commercial endeavours.

Yeah, but you don't act like ''whatever'' when your fave has top grossing tour... Gaga's perfume is fantastic and well deserved this number of the sales, after all i don't know why are people this surprised, she's declared as the most famous celebrity of 2012 by guinness and has 2nd top grossing tour of 2012....

[newwil7l]

Originally posted by BlondeAmbitionxX

Yeah, but you don't act like ''whatever'' when your fave has top grossing tour etc... Gaga's perfume is fantastic and well deserved this, after all i don't know why are people this surprised, she's declared as the most famous celebrity of 2012 by guinness and has 2nd top grossing tour of 2012....

This 100%
The haters will remain seething. just because they're faves could never

[rbautz]

Very impressive retailer sales for the fragrance and congrats. to Lady Gaga.

I ask my-self how many revenue will have H&M with Lana's fall collection?

And will Lana brag about it, on Twitter?

Questions upon questions.

[BlondeAmbitionxX]

Originally posted by rbautz

Very impressive retailer sales for the fragrance and congrats. to Lady Gaga.

I ask my-self how many revenue will have H&M with Lana's fall collection?

And will Lana brag about it, on Twitter?

Questions upon questions.

It's not bragging, she was overwhelmed and surprised at the amount of bottles sold out... she basically thanked everybody for supporting her...

[Retro]

Originally posted by ABEL-o-matic

I don't get why they can't respect other people's criticisms.

You're not "criticising" anything. You're claiming the figures provided are false with no source to contradict them yet. It was fine when at first you simply expressed doubt, but then you went straight to stating the figures were false when there is no evidence to support that claim.

[rbautz]

Originally posted by BlondeAmbitionxX

It's not bragging, she was overwhelmed and surprised at the amount of bottles sold out... she basically thanked everybody for supporting her...

It's for me more about music. Why should I buy a fragrance because of an ad of Lady Gaga why should I buy a sweater because of an ad of Lana?

In short: If you are a singer. Sing.

[HausofKen]

All i see is other stans complaining in this thread ! i know you all wish your fave can sell 6M in 1week !

[Cal]

YAS THE GOD OF POP! SLAY!



THE FUMES UP IN HERE.



SING WITH ME! I'M GONNA MARRY THE NIGHT! I'M NOT GONNA CRY ANYMORE!

[Retro]

Originally posted by rbautz

It's for me more about music. Why should I buy a fragrance because of an ad of Lady Gaga why should I buy a sweater because of an ad of Lana?

In short: If you are a singer. Sing.

She does. Are singers not allowed to do anything else but sing, ever?

[YSL]

Omg the people in here are being so ridiculous. Save your energy for IF a report says it DIDN'T sell that many bottles. Right now you all just look like a bunch of pressed assholes.

I'm glad this thread was re-opened since Vincent was not a reliable enough source.

[BlondeAmbitionxX]

Originally posted by rbautz

It's for me more about music. Why should I buy a fragrance because of an ad of Lady Gaga why should I buy a sweater because of an ad of Lana?

In short: If you are a singer. Sing.

You obviously strayed in POP music accidently, POP music was never only about singing and never will be, it's about every aspect of life of one pop star, do you really think all the biggest icons like MJ and Madonna would be this successful if they just sang songs....

[Devon]

6 million is a bit of a fishy number, and I don't care for Gaga, but her perfume smells AMAZING

[Rentboy]

Originally posted by BlondeAmbitionxX

Yeah, but you don't act like ''whatever'' when your fave has top grossing tour... Gaga's perfume is fantastic and well deserved this number of the sales, after all i don't know why are people this surprised, she's declared as the most famous celebrity of 2012 by guinness and has 2nd top grossing tour of 2012....

No you will never ever see me bragging about how much money my faves make. I avoid Forbes threads because I find them irrelevant to music. I stan for music artists not business people.

I will brag about chart positions and record sales however. Because that represents their musics success.

Perfume I couldn't give a toss about. Every minor celeb and their mother has a perfume out these days. If you crave money, release a perfume. Some music artists just dont chase the cash like that.

[Harajuku]

Ya'll are pressed

[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by HausofKen

All i see is other stans complaining in this thread ! i know you all wish your fave can sell 6M in 1week !

My fave is Michael Buble, so there's no need to justify.

[BlondeAmbitionxX]

Originally posted by Rentboy

No you will never ever see me bragging about how much money my faves make. I avoid Forbes threads because I find them irrelevant to music. I stan for music artists not business people.

I will brag about chart positions and record sales however. Because that represents their musics success.

Perfume I couldn't give a toss about. Every minor celeb and their mother has a perfume out these days. If you crave money, release a perfume. Some music artists just dont chase the cash like that.

I doubt that Gaga chase money, she loves attention but not that much money tbh, she puts all her money in to the show and costumes so in the end it's all about music and performance, it's not like she lives in Hollywood mansion and drive expensive cars....

[ElectricFrancis]

The pressed can't take the Queen's success. Poor things



Your faves will never.

[GGD]

seethe ... seethe .... seething bitches everywhere

[Mr Telephone Man]

Originally posted by ABEL-o-matic

I don't get why they can't respect other people's criticisms.

Exactly! And asking for a legitimate source, that isn't GaGa repeating word for word what her manager said in some backroom radio interview (all the while comparing it to "Coco Chanel" which isn't even a fragrance), isn't being pressed.

You would think Euromonitor International, and Forbes would be reporting about this "significant" achievement, and Coty would be sending out press releases left and right supporting the fact, if it was true.

And it wouldn't be the first time her label has confused shipments for sales, and yes fragrances, just like most products, run in shipments.