| |
Tournament: Survivor (The TV Show) : ATRL Edition! [Season 1!]
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
results coming in a bit...anyway i want you guys to know i am the new host of the kelly clarkson non singles game  i stole that thread 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/18/2012
Posts: 27,141
|
finally!!
and thanx for overtaking that flop ass kelly MC!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/27/2011
Posts: 36,557
|
I'm still at my party and no results
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Hi guys! I'm really sorry about the wait  Let's see what your pathetic EP's sound like
Only 1 contestant will receive immunity and only one will receive an automatic vote.
You will be judged on points[/40].
ethan: Katy Perry - Teenage Dream The Complete Confection
1. Teenage Dream
2. ET feat. Kanye West
3. Last Friday Night
4. Hummingbird Heartbeat
5. Firework
6. Not Like the Movies
7. Wide Awake
Quote:
Ray Bass: 9. "Call Cali Gurls whatever you wanna call it, but I needed it there! That's the perfect lead single to this era.
I do loved your explanation hours ago Ethan though, but even if I believe there's songs that well support this EP and would have a lead single status easily,
California Gurls is really missing out for me in here, that's why I can't hand you a perfect score."
|
Quote:
Alexz - 10 - You got me when you included Godmmingbird Heartbeat and Not Like The Movies I would have liked you included TOTGA but I don't see it fitting in you team so it's ok 
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 10/10: Perfect selections, perfect order, perfect beginning, perfect ending, perfect everything. Enough said!
|
medosuxx: Rihanna - Talk That Talk
1. Where Have You Been
2. Watch N' Learn
3. Roc Me Out
4. Talk That Talk
5. Do Ya Thang
6. Drunk On Love
7. We Found Love
Deluxe Edition Track: Red Lipstick
Deluxe Edition Hidden Track: Where Have You Been (Yashar Gasanov Remix)
Quote:
Ray Bass: 10. "You see Medo, TTT may one of the weakest albums in here, but it made it easier for you to select which tracks were worthy of appearing in an EP, and I'm very glad you considered WNL as that's my personal favorite from the album. The rest of the track selection is flawless and I would change NOTHING! Great job, I even listened to the WHYB remix and got me bumping!
By the way, you need to teach me those editing skills you have for the TTT mini booklet you made, amazing!"
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 10 - Perfect EP, I love all the songs on it and I like it that you started with WHYB and finished with We Found Love.
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 9.5/10: Starting a with a smash and ending with a smash. Great decision. I love how you put We Found Love as the ending track. It honestly just slays over everything so it ends the EP with a bang. Great choices in song selection too, but maybe you should have replaced Do Ya Thang with the Birthday Cake Remix. Oh and Red Lipstick
|
AllThat****ery: Britney Spears - In The Zone
1. Toxic
2. Showdown
3. Outrageous
4. Touch Of My Hand
5. Breathe On Me
6. Shadow
7. Everytime
Quote:
Ray Bass: 7. "I'mma call someone in here, because I'm not here for MATM being paid dust this way.
Even Early Mornin' was snubbed and that Urban-tingled jam gets me groovy every time.
TOMH is very weak in my honest opinion. If this was up to me and I was biased, I would of course include
the crunk-influenced I Got That (Boom Boom) featuring the Ying Yang Twins, but even I know that's not worthy of making the cut in an ITZ EP.
I'm mainly upset MATM didn't made the cut, it got all the buzz going around this album back in the day because of the publicity stunt that happened moths before at the 2003 VMAs, so this collabo got the hype around the record, and Toxic just cemented its status."
|
Quote:
Alexz- - 9 - I know you are not a fan and that you had a hard time choosing the songs, but I can't believe you didn't pick Me Against the Music, Hook Up and I Got That (Boom Boom) :jonny; I guess you asked a Brinty fan or something because Touch of My Hand?  but oh well, at least you included Shadow and Everytime  well done!
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 10/10: This EP is perfect. Every standout song from In the Zone is here so fantastic job and fantastic order.
|
theREALslimSHADY: Taylor Swift - Speak Now
1. Sparks Fly
2. Speak Now
3. Back To December
4. Enchanted
5. Last Kiss
6. Haunted
7. Mean
8. Long Live
Quote:
DillonATRL - 9.5 - If Speak Now wasn't the title track I'd bash you endlessly since that song is not a standout at all...the rest is very good and i;m glad you chose Mean as it shows a real country side of Taylor...the track order is good as well so impressive slimSHADy! 
|
Quote:
Ray Bass: 9. "I'm glad you listened to what I had to say about Mean. It adds the country-flavor to the EP, that the other songs lack.
Sparks Fly would've done wonders as a lead single instead of Mine, and I agree with everything else.. but how in the world were Better Than Revenge or The Story of Us snubbed in favor for Long Live! I can even let go Last Kiss which is also inferior to the previous two I've mentioned because its a different type of song and it's actually kinda cute, and even though I love Long Live, TSOU's lyricism is wonderful, and BTR is angry Taylor at its best, those lyrics you can't find anywere!
That bitch is underestimating Taylor, and she'll get her revenge. I love that song and I can't believe you left it out.. its different from what Taylor has done but not a complete U-turn from her previous work... in your description of "Rock/Pop" Taylor, I would rather think of a song as "Eyes Open" before considering "Better Than Revenge" a rock song. Anyways, its a great job nonetheless, that was my only issue with the song selection."
|
Quote:
Alexz - 9.5 - I love that you included Haunted and Mean, and yes...I read your essay but I think Ours and Dear John would have been a better pick  lol no but seriously, those are just  but still, you did an amazing job.
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 10/10: I read it, and I think you did a great job this round. The song order is pretty much perfect and Long Live is definitely the best ending track possible so great job!
|
DanceForYou: Beyonce - I Am Sasha Fierce
1. Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)
2. Diva
3. Sweet Dreams
4. Halo
5. Smash Into You
6. If I Were A Boy
7. Broken-Hearted Girl
8. Radio
Quote:
DillonATRL - 9.5 - I could've done withotu Radio but the stans like it so i guess that's okay...only issue that you will be bashed endlessly for is not letting Smash Into You END the EP..it's a flawless way to end the EP..other than that perfect! 
|
Quote:
Ray Bass: 10. "The exact eight songs I would pick for IASF are here.
I would consider Ave Maria, but in the end would've got snubbed in favor of the eight songs above, excellent job DFY."
|
Quote:
Alexz - 9.5 - Flawless EP, specially because you picked Smash Into Billboard it really has a cohesion, I would have loved you included Scared of Lonely  anyway, great job!
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 8/10: I'm not too fond of Radio being the last track. I think Halo would have been the best choice for the last track. Otherwise, nice job this round.
|
TimmyInTheWell: Kelly Clarkson - Stronger
1. Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)
2. I Forgive You
3. Honestly
4. Dark Side
5. You Can't Win
6. The War Is Over
7. Let Me Down
Quote:
Ray Bass: 8. "Five Words. WHERE IS: YOU LOVE ME? That's the freaking best song in the album and you left it out in favor of You Can't Win The War Is Over... I can't.
The rest is good, though, that's why your score can't go down that much, but I'm pretty shocked at having YCW or TWIO over YLM.
I would even consider the epic Why Don't You Try as a bonus track to the EP too, but that's overthinking."
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 9.5 - Perfect, this album is just amazing, and you picked some of best song, I would have loved you included Hello or Alone, but still you did great Timmy.
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 7/10: Why the cyrus is everyone so in love with Let Me Down. That song does not deserve to be here. Einstein does, and I think Stronger should be last, I Forgive You could be first and the rest is fine except Einstein should be #6.
|
rihannabiggestfan: Rihanna - Good Girl Gone Bad Reloaded
1: Don't Stop the Music
2: Umbrella
3: Disturbia
4: Shut Up and Drive
5: Breaking Dishes
6: Take a Bow
7: Good Girl Gone Bad
Quote:
|
Ray Bass: 10. "I wouldn't argue a thing, I even agree that GGGB or Rehab can take the last spot because you need another ballad to support the up-tempo first half of the EP, and GGGB is a good song to give that role to. Great job!!"
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 10 - Disturbia is... oh my. first time hearing it, I love it! You did a great job picking up the best songs, a great EP.
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 8/10: I don't think Shut Up And Drive should be here. Instead I think Breakin' Dishes should be 4th, and then Rehab. Sorry but Rehab is a masterpiece and you leaving it out is a disgrace to Rihanna. Otherwise, everything else is good.
|
borntodie: Rihanna - Loud
1. Fading
2. S&M
3. California King Bed
4. What's My Name? (feat. Drake)
5. Love The Way You Lie (Part II) (feat. Eminem)
6. Only Girl (In The World)
Quote:
DillonATRL - 9 - I feel the same as Ray about Skin...that song is so perfect but it woulds not be included on a EP of LOUD anyway so that's alright...however you really should have added Man Down and switched tracks 1 and 2  still good job Anna 
|
Quote:
Ray Bass: 8.5 "Six songs on an EP are very few to judge on, and OG, WMN, S&M and LTWYL2 were shoe-ins on songs that had to be there. I like the inclusion of Fading as its a personal favorite, but being not-biased, I can't agree its one of the songs I'd leave on a 6-song edition of Loud. I would rather have the Caribbean-tingled Man Down in there, and leave CKB as the ballad that will support LTWYL2 as the soothing ballads in the album. And I would hate Loud being an EP, as I love Skin so much, its so sexy, and sadly I don't think it would make the cut in the end 
Anyways, out of the Fading thing, everything its on point, kudos BTD!"
|
Quote:
|
Alexz - 9.5 - I think it was a great idea including Fading, definitely a great song, but where's Man Down tho? Anyway, Great EP.
|
Quote:
MLD: 5/10: Who thought it was a good idea to put FADING as the opening track? That chiz ain't powerful enough. Not only that but Only Girl does not deserve to be the last track. It should be first. Love the Way You Lie Part 2 should be last, and Raining Men should be here instead of Fading. Honestly, this is just a mess 
|
Leaderboard
1. medosuxx: 39 IMMUNE
2. ethan: 38
2. rihannabiggestfan: 38
2. theREALslimSHADY: 38
3. DanceForYou: 37
4. AllThat****ery: 34.5
5. TimmyInTheWell: 34
6. borntodie: 32  1 VOTE ADDED
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/27/2011
Posts: 36,557
|
I'm happy. Almost got immunity though but it's okay. I'm happy I didn't include Push Up on Me. I wonder what you would have rated my ep of Loud
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Quote:
Originally posted by rihannabiggestfan
I'm happy. Almost got immunity though but it's okay. I'm happy I didn't include Push Up on Me. I wonder what you would have rated my ep of Loud |
if it included man down at least 9
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/27/2011
Posts: 36,557
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
if it included man down at least 9 |
It does, I'll link it to you tomorrow. It includes Skin though because that is the epitome of Loud, a musthave
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2011
Posts: 15,524
|
Happy with my score, it seems everyone agreed with the song choices at least. Wooot.
And yes Alexz, Scared of Lonely was one of my two alternate choices, along with Ego. SOL is so beautiful.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Quote:
Originally posted by rihannabiggestfan
It does, I'll link it to you tomorrow. It includes Skin though because that is the epitome of Loud, a musthave
|
I'm not gonna start with Skin...  it's so hot.....:sex:
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DanceForYou
Happy with my score, it seems everyone agreed with the song choices at least. Wooot.
And yes Alexz, Scared of Lonely was one of my two alternate choices, along with Ego. SOL is so beautiful. |
Smash Into You >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>> Beyonce
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2011
Posts: 15,524
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
Smash Into You >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>> Ke$ha and quite a few other pop gurlz
|
True.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/27/2011
Posts: 36,557
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
I'm not gonna start with Skin... it's so hot.....:sex: |
Lol ikr. Thanks for the "best round" comment Dillon and I'm glad you liked Disturbia, Four. I'm surprised you haven't heard it lol
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DanceForYou
True. |
Ke$ha >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> me!.....ok let's not get crazy but she's
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/22/2012
Posts: 33,490
|
I did not want to start out with one of the super upbeat in your face tracks, that's why I chose fading as the opener, so the energy could build from that. Opposed to that, I put Only Girl as the last song for a perhaps unexpected strong finish after the ballad. Ballads usually come last in the track list and I think that's a bit boring. I was thinking about including Man Down, but for an EP it seemed a bit too different and I wanted it to be cohesive.
just a small explanation. and congrats to Medo for winning!
|
|
|
|
Banned
Member Since: 6/12/2012
Posts: 6,002
|
guys sorry i havent been active, ive actually been gone doing MEDS and i havent been able to use my cellphone...I just got sworn into the Navy today guys
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Quote:
Originally posted by AllThat****ery
guys sorry i havent been active, ive actually been gone doing MEDS and i havent been able to use my cellphone...I just got sworn into the Navy today guys |
Congrats
i'm going bye bye send those votes in guys.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/18/2012
Posts: 27,141
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/18/2012
Posts: 27,141
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/18/2012
Posts: 27,141
|
Quote:
|
MLD: 10/10: I read it, and I think you did a great job this round. The song order is pretty much perfect and Long Live is definitely the best ending track possible so great job!
|
i cant thank you enough ryan for recognizing that!!
Quote:
|
DillonATRL - 9.5 - If Speak Now wasn't the title track I'd bash you endlessly since that song is not a standout at all...the rest is very good and i;m glad you chose Mean as it shows a real country side of Taylor...the track order is good as well so impressive slimSHADy!
|
there's no way i would have put speak now in there had it not been a title track! 
Quote:
|
Alexz - 9.5 - I love that you included Haunted and Mean, and yes...I read your essay but I think Ours and Dear John would have been a better pick lol no but seriously, those are just but still, you did an amazing job.
|
i was so confused between mine/mean/ours .. and .. LK/DJ/innocent, i was about to make a poll! 
but thanx for only cutting 0.5 marks
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/18/2010
Posts: 10,698
|
Dear John and Never Grow Up are the weakest songs on Speak Now, there's no way there should've been included in an EP.
|
|
|
|
|
|
but you did a great job although i would prefer Farewell as maybe the bonus track or the replacement of Roc Me Ou. But i like how you added that really nice WHYB Remix 
so great job medo! 
but overally i think you did a good job. Although it seems like you grouped the tracks in order...like you have the two sex anthems in a row followed by the two ballads...nonetheless good job Drew! 
...NO! that is a iconic duet 
...8.5 now 
its my personal favourite off the album, better than hanted or enchanted! 
