Quote:
Originally posted by theREALslimSHADY
no really, its exactly the same; the melody! same key, same tempo! the intro of scientist and haunted(acoustic) are same thus!
and i just meant that that i LOVED the melody of haunted, but if it was taken from scientist it brings down the value!
the songs are different, but listen to the instrumentals of both songs(haunted acoustic!) and they are the same(just taylor adds more production as it progresses!)
|
It's not the same melody , the melody relies mostly on the vocals , and the vocals of both songs sound nothing like each other .
The melody of :
You and I walk a fragile line , I have known it all this time but I never thought I'd live to see it break. and
Come up to meet you ... tell you I'm sorry , you don't know how lovely you are .
Sound nothing alike , and you can sing both to try that .
If you strip down Sparks Fly with a Piano it'll sound like them too.
Yes , the way of them playing the piano is very similar , but again , that only makes the instrumental similar.
And actually the chords change faster in Haunted .
Yes , the intros sound close , but the melody of the vocals is extremely different .
I mean you could find 1000 other songs that sound just like that , and not because it's un-original , but it's because chords used in Music today are the easiest , they might look different , but you can play them in MANY different ways .
The trick is that one chord has more than 10 different shapes .
And as I said , they sound similar because the way of playing is similar .
The similar chords are something VERY common today .