The lowdown: Written by a pre-fame Taylor, this ode to a guy that's "just wrong enough to [...] feel right" became a fan favorite after she performed it live at early concerts. Following requests, it was included on Speak Now and then released as the album's fifth single, becoming her first #1 country hit since "You Belong With Me."
The vote: Buoyed by ten 10's and only nine scores below 7, "Sparks Fly" never left the top twenty, and briefly climbed into the top ten, throughout the course of voting.
Best line: "You're the kind of reckless that should send me running/but I kinda know that I won't get far"