[Evangeline]

Which song is better?Which one is more iconic WW?

[MiguelPortugal]

Crazy In Love.

[lpd446]

Umbrella for both of those questions

[Boomer]

CIL was higher on pretty much every decade-end list.

[SLAYANNA NAVY]

Better song= Umbrella
More iconic= Crazy In Love

[Quiqui4eva]

Crazy In Love

[MiguelPortugal]

Originally posted by Boomer

CIL was higher on pretty much every decade-end list.

Case closed.

[Ozzy8923]

I like Umbrella as a song more, but Crazy in Love is more memorable (Iconic is a stupid word that is constantly used on this website for the most trivial things).

[Kanji]

Umbrella

[evo]

Neck and neck

[Shaliydah88]

Crazy in Love for more iconic.
Crazy in Love for better song.

[Kang.]

Ummm....

CIL for both, I guess

[touchofmyhand]

Umbrella duh

[Praise Mariallah]

If ya'll don't stop with the word iconic.

Just..

[RatedG²]

CIL and the critics agree so this isn't even a choice. I don't know why it's a poll

[Evangeline]

Originally posted by Ozzy8923

I like Umbrella as a song more, but Crazy in Love is more memorable (Iconic is a stupid word that is constantly used on this website for the most trivial things).

I agree that it is overused,but CIL and Umbrella ARE iconic in every sense,so.

[Mr.Marvelous]

Umbrella.

[Mélina]

CIL for both.

[KK_Lover]

UMBRELLA

[Rhythm]

It's inevitable that this will essentially become an assessment of which was more successful (chart-wise). Before that happens, I'll go on the record and state that "Crazy in Love" is more culturally significant than "Umbrella" is.