So, off one listen.
You've got Human, Losing Touch, Spaceman - obvious winners. Huge choruses, anthems to the nines. Joy Ride and Neon Tiger have their flaws, but they work well for the most part and will sound great live.
But other than that? Everything else kinda falls flat. Dustland Fairytale, Crippling Blow, Forget About What I Said - have some glimpse of hope, but never really get off the ground. And the rest? Let's just say I can't even remember their titles. That's how boring I found the rest (in the same vain as "Everything Will Be Alright" or "Believe Me Natalie" minus the synths)
Overall, there is nothing that touches the likes of When You Were Young or Read My Mind - let alone ANYTHING off of Hot Fuss.
Maybe it'll be a grower? I hope to God it's a grower. 6/10 for now. But definitely their weakest effort to date