[adrianbeane]

''MDNA'' vs ''Aphrodite''

''Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

[iamanearthling]

Both
gang bang
i'm addicted
tutr
gmayl
aphrodite
i dun give a
i'm a sinner
love spent
masterpiece
cbtf
beautiful killer
i ****ed up
b day song

[WFL]

MDNA!

[AccurateSketch]

actually, I vote "Aphrodite"

[Rainer]

'MDNA'.

[Ignacio]

'Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

[Phunk]

''Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

[freebitch26]

Aphrodite >>>>>>

[Parks]

''Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way'' (Can't choose. Won't choose.)
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs "Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

8-8 TIE. Love both albums.

[Glamthony]

''Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

[Ace Reject]

'All the Lovers''
''Get Outta My Way''
'Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio''
''Everything is Beautiful''
''Aphrodite''
''Superstar''
''Better Than Today''
Too Much''
''Cupid Boy''
''Looking For An Angel''
''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer''
''I ****ed Up''
'Go Hard or Go Home''

[Miracle]

Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''
Anyway, I like Aphrodite more like a full album

[adrianbeane]

''Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much''
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

''MDNA'' (8) vs ''Aphrodite'' (7)

Note: ''Aphrodite'' would actually win if I had to compare both album as a whole and not track-by-track.

[madonnas]

''Girl Gone Wild'' vs ''All the Lovers''
''Gang Bang'' vs ''Get Outta My Way''
''I'm Addicted'' vs ''Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)''
''Turn Up the Radio'' vs ''Closer''
''Give Me All Your Luvin''' vs ''Everything is Beautiful''
''Some Girls'' vs ''Aphrodite''
''Superstar'' vs ''Illusion''
''I Don't Give A'' vs ''Better Than Today''
''I'm A Sinner'' vs ''Too Much'' tie (both are 10/10)
''Love Spent'' vs ''Cupid Boy''
''Masterpiece'' vs ''Looking For An Angel''
''Falling Free'' vs ''Can't Beat the Feeling''
bonus tracks
''Beautiful Killer'' vs ''Mighty Rivers''
''I ****ed Up'' vs ''Heartstrings''
''B-Day Song'' vs ''Go Hard or Go Home''

[zach]

I really dislike Aphrodite, so MDNA for all