[mandym]

Kelly.

[briannaisboss]

Kelly

[SIMon1120]

Kelly

[Glam]

Thankful vs Some Hearts
Breakaway vs Carnival Ride
My December vs Play On
All I Ever Wanted vs Blown Away


It's funny cause Carnival Ride is my favorite Carrie album but it can't win against Breakaway.

So many of you didn't read OP, good job

[Hunter_13]

Thankful vs Some Hearts
Breakaway vs Carnival Ride
My December vs Play On
All I Ever Wanted vs Blown Away

I actually like Carnival Ride, but it being against Breakway. No way.

[MissBreakaway]

This again I prefer Kelly though, I don't know much of Carrie's stuff.

[DejaVu]

Thankful vs Some Hearts
Breakaway vs Carnival Ride
My December vs Play On
All I Ever Wanted vs Blown Away

Kelly

[Ulquiorra Allen]

Thankful vs Some Hearts
Breakaway vs Carnival Ride
My December vs Play On
All I Ever Wanted vs Blown Away

Kelly overall. I only lean towards Some Hearts because Thankful is simply horrid.

[Nerevanin]

Kelly for all. I'm not much into country, tbh.

[MCBeth]

Now: Adele vs Amy Winehouse



'19' vs Frank
'21' vs Back to Black
disqualified ◄ Lioness: Hidden Treasures

Already done

Madonna vs. Janet (winner: Madonna)
J.Lo vs Rihanna (winner: Rihanna)
David Bowie vs Prince (winner: David Bowie)
Lady Gaga vs Lana Del Rey (winner: Lady Gaga)
Kelly Clarkson vs Carrie Underwood (winner: Kelly Clarkson)

[Ichinaru19]

ADELE

[Stevie]

Amy! Adele's can be a bit on a boring side.

[ReflectingGod]

Amy! Back to Black > Adele

[Robert]

Amy by far. Adele's music is good but it lacks the diversity and uniqueness of Amy's. Back To Black is one of my fave albums ever.

[Remember When]

Amy

[Bríseis]

Amy

[nicklada]

Amy easily. Not even a competition.

[AndresVanDeKamp]

Amy. Back To Black >>>>

[jqnetto]

Amy.

[jordanjm]

Amy and it's not even close.