[BSNMology]

Britney.

Beyonce's "you you you"s sound like she has to vomit. Britney's voice suits the verses better as well IMO. Beyonce sounds like a dramatic reading in theater class.

Also, when I hear Britney's version, I feel emotion because of Britney's past. Beyonce's just feels like a standard performance, and I hate how she connects it with If I Were A Boy.

Of course Beyonce is the superior singer overall, but with this specific song, I def prefer Britney.

[Xalric]

For the hears Beyoncé's version is better, but she did oversing (like she used to in the past with some DC tracks) and she's not really connected to the song. Yes Vocally I still prefer Beyoncé than Britney, but Britney gives more emotions to it.

I voted Beyoncé because Vocal is ++ for me, And also she's my faves

PS: I don't know why this simple innocent thread turned into a big stan war mess...