[Subomie]

American Life has got to be the worst case of overrating I've ever seen.
At least her other overrated works, ROL and COADF, are decent, AL sucks

[Lifeline]

You either "GET" American Life or you simply claim it sucks



and songs like 'Easy Ride', 'Intervention' and 'Love Profusion' definitely do NOT suck.


"Girl bye"

[Subomie]

I "GET" American Life, it just sucks

Just because a song has a message doesn't make it any better. I'll stick to Erotica if I want controversial Madonna.

[Stevie]

The top 20 will probably just be a battle of the pop girls, but hopefully Amy can come from behind and pull off the win.

[rnbey]

Originally posted by Subomie

I "GET" American Life, it just sucks

Just because a song has a message doesn't make it any better. I'll stick to Erotica if I want controversial Madonna.

Right.

I don't know how you can't "get" American Life, it has all the subtlety of a sledgehammer.

[Lucas32]

#20
307 points
Green Day – American Idiot

1x21(Lucas32)
1x13(abrahamjmr)
1x22(ClassicMainstream)
1x15(superben)
1x22(King Of R&B)
1x13(Gangsta4alie)
1x13(Chill Bill)
1x50(Gabrielmm)
1x16(Caleb)
1x15(Brando)
1x22(Euphoria)
1x19(dinorel)
1x13(Ulrihs)
1x12(MCBeth)
1x22(Frantic)
1x16(KarlosVzla)
Favorite song: American Idiot/Boulevard of broken dreams





Amazing album
The title track is among my favorite songs ever

[madonnas]

The title track is cool and a few other tracks are great, overall it's just ok imo.

[Stevie]

Was not expecting to see that.

It has a few great songs but it's not really my cup of tea.

[Subomie]

Those tracks are nice

[Princedele21]

It's not that great.

[ECNEICSNOC]

I remember the singles from American Idiot being good.

Now... 19 albums left

In the Zone
Blackout
The Fame
The Fame Monster
Rated R
Good Girl Gone Bad
Music
Bible'Day
Back To Christ
Godonia

.....I'm drawing a blank now.

[Haus-Of_Mck]

Great album

Boulevard was my **** for months

[Subomie]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

I remember the singles from American Idiot being good.

Now... 19 albums left

In the Zone
Blackout
The Fame
The Fame Monster
Rated R
Good Girl Gone Bad
Music
Bible'Day
Back To Christ
Godonia

.....I'm drawing a blank now.

Love Angel Music Baby
Lungs
Kala

...

Tasty?

[madonnas]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

I remember the singles from American Idiot being good.

Now... 19 albums left

In the Zone
Blackout
The Fame
The Fame Monster
Rated R
Good Girl Gone Bad
Music
Bible'Day
Back To Christ
Godonia

.....I'm drawing a blank now.

Kid A?

[ECNEICSNOC]

Originally posted by Subomie

Love Angel Music Baby
Lungs
Kala

...

Tasty?

LAMB, Kala, and Kid A for sure. Tasty is a long shot. I haven't heard of Lungs. Maybe The Dutchess?

[Lifeline]

The Dutchess left us long ago

I'd like the flop albums that didn't make the top 100 to continue by the way

[Stevie]

Didn't Music show up already?

YES at Kid A, Back to Black, Lungs, and even Kala still being here. This top 20 might not be so bad after all.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

LAMB, Kala, and Kid A for sure. Tasty is a long shot. I haven't heard of Lungs. Maybe The Dutchess?

It's a Florence + the Machine album
The Dutchess is out already.

[ECNEICSNOC]

Is Lovers Rock too much of a long shot?

[Lucas32]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

LAMB, Kala, and Kid A for sure. Tasty is a long shot. I haven't heard of Lungs. Maybe The Dutchess?

You better get into the best album of the decade

Originally posted by Stevie

Didn't Music show up already?

YES at Kid A, Back to Black, Lungs, and even Kala still being here. This top 20 might not be so bad after all.

No it didn't