[Stephen]

Originally posted by Kats

Under any circumstance, she is prettier than your fave and you can't deal with it. You tried though to knock out a beauty. Gurl bye.

When did I mention my fave being pretty? Keep trying to make this about Gaga, and post a picture of Katy with caked-on makeup.

My original 2-4 (depending on the circumstances) range remains:

[Auburn]

Originally posted by Stephen

When did I mention my fave being pretty? Keep trying to make this about Gaga, and post a picture of Katy with caked-on makeup.

My original 2-4 (depending on the circumstances) range remains:

So you base your opinions on absolute worst photos of people?

[2AM]

Originally posted by Stephen

When did I mention my fave being pretty? Keep trying to make this about Gaga, and post a picture of Katy with caked-on makeup.

My original 2-4 (depending on the circumstances) range remains:

Calm down sis, your the one who is pressed. It's okay, you can bring up all you want, but no body except Gaga stans have gave her below a 4. What's that tell you?

[MovinKindaSlow]

2.5 she's a completely different person without make up

[muziq.kid]

2 She's ok

[2AM]

Originally posted by stereo.love

So you base your opinions on absolute worst photos of people?

Of course he is. He only has a handful of worse pictures of Katy, we have hundreds. There goes his logic.

[Lyzz the Monster]

Originally posted by Kats

Calm down sis, your the one who is pressed. It's okay, you can bring up all you want, but no body except Gaga stans have gave her below a 4. What's that tell you?

I gave her a 4.
Respect each other's opinion please. These Gaga stans all give Katy at least 3.
Some people gave gaga 0 and we had to deal as well.

[Mzd]

A solid 4

[_Monster_]

I give her a 3.5
if she got a tan... & dyed her hair back to black she'd be a 5

[Stephen]

Originally posted by Lyzz the Monster

I gave her a 4.
Respect each other's opinion please. These Gaga stans all give Katy at least 3.
Some people gave gaga 0 and we had to deal as well.

Yup. Also, if we take a look at the score breakdown:

4 - lightly beautiful, a bit stunning
3 - average beauty
2 - a heavy make-up will help

I don't see how applying any of these to Katy is wrong. Heavy makeup does help her and I had the receipts. Other than that, I think she's somewhere between average and lightly beautiful. Out of all the girls listed, I only would give Beyonce a 5. I gave no indication of being "pressed." I merely stated my opinion and backed it up, without resorting to talking about Gaga.

[2AM]

Originally posted by Lyzz the Monster

I gave her a 4.
Respect each other's opinion please. These Gaga stans all give Katy at least 3.
Some people gave gaga 0 and we had to deal as well.

I know. I said everyone that gave her below a 4 at the time I posted that were Gaga stans, which is true. I respect people's opinions, but when they are clearly pressed, I'm going to say something. Some gave Gaga a 0, sorry you had to deal with it.

[RihSexual]

4

[Lyzz the Monster]

Originally posted by Kats

I know. I said everyone that gave her below a 4 at the time I posted that were Gaga stans, which is true. I respect people's opinions, but when they are clearly pressed, I'm going to say something. Some gave Gaga a 0, sorry you had to deal with it.

The Kats need to stop worried. ATRL will give her a 4 or 5 average score based on these ratings.

[!ola]

3.

[Wii]

5

[h.u.r.r.i.c.a.n.e]

5.
It's not just the looks, it's her personality.
And I've met her in person, she is beyond gorgeous.



And she doesn't need to be wearing something fancy or be on the red carpet to look beautiful.

[beyoncefan1]

4. I would give her a 5 if it wasn't for her changing to that tacky Rainbow Brite pink hair.

[Dale]

[Ripedie254]

5

[Brooklyn]

5