[blackbeatxx]

^yeah...lol @ "sounds"

[Delicious]

Mary J Blige couldnt pull off Umbrella better than Rihanna. Mary's a boring bitch and the song wouldnt be as exciting or fun. I'm pretty sure if Mary did it, it wouldnt have been #1

[blackbeatxx]

i agree, umbrella was made for a young pop-voice

[.:Allen:.]

I dont see her singing it

[Anthony K.]

I can't imagine Mary J. Blige singing 'Umbrella'... She would probably have turned it in a ballad. lol
But LMAO, this song was made for everyone BUT Rihanna, yet she was the lucky one who got to make it a huge hit.

[Martin]

Originally posted by ozlovezashlee

shes got a long way 2 go

yeah, and Long way to go has a Looooooooooooooooong Way to go to get on #1 honey!
That's the fact!

[Rodrigo]

i would like to see a version of Umbrella for each artist who said that it was intented
MJ Blige would be intersting maybe good
Britney... i dont know .. may be good too

[1-N-Only21]

britney would kill the song...she can't sing and rihanna can't really sing either but that island voice made it so catchy

[Martin]

^ ditto!

[WAЯЯEN]

Damn, they offered this song to everyone.

[sGabe4]

^maybe everybody thought it would be a flop

[!Tofer!]

well im happy rihanna got it because i dont think it would be anywhere near as big if mary J woulda done it

[Exodus]

LMAO. That would have been a terrible flop for Mary J. Blige. Too silly of a song for her.

[xoxokely]

Originally posted by !Tofer!

well im happy rihanna got it because i dont think it would be anywhere near as big if mary J woulda done it

yea. you're right...and rihanna would really make it more fresh...AND YOUNG