[supaspaz]

No no no! I'm devastated by the elimination of "She Said She Said" and "Pet Sounds." Both of them were worthy of the top ten. Hell, "Pet Sounds" should have been a contender for the #1 spot!

"Love You To" is also out way too early. It's so innovative and interesting! What didn't voters like about it?

[Brando]

Originally posted by supaspaz

Hell, "Pet Sounds" should have been a contender for the #1 spot!

Nope

Originally posted by supaspaz

"Love You To" is also out way too early. It's so innovative and interesting! What didn't voters like about it?

The arrangements are great, but the vocal parts are a bit meh for me. I gave it a 7 I think.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Brando

Nope

The anti-instrumental bias is real.

[jqnetto]

I thought all Miles' songs would get basically the same average. "All Blues" must be the next one out of his album to leave the countdown.

Beatles' best songs are still in, so I'm okay with these Revolver's eliminations.

Some "What's Going On" and "Thriller" in the next update, please.

[Brando]

Originally posted by supaspaz

The anti-instrumental bias is real.

No bias here. My highest average was for Kind of Blue

[FattMatt]

The Girl is Mine - Song sucked anyways
Tha Ledy in ma Life - sucked
Yellow Submarine - this classic should not be this low
Revolution Rock - eh
Four Horsemen - done wrong
Let's Go Away for a While - THE **** IS THIS ****. one of the best songs on Pet Sounds and the critics agree it is the more interesting instrumental
Baby Be Mine - Again a great track
God is Love - Love dis Song, but the atheists of ATRL would get it out smh (JK)
Wrong em Boyo - nice song
Save the Children - this song is a masterpiece, i got chills listening to this
Koka Kola - *throws up*
I Want to Tell You - eh
PYT - I actually love this song
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) - kinda boring
And Your Bird Can Sing - no
Jimmy Jazz - eh
The Right Profile - I love this song but its placement is deserved
Freddie Freeloader - nice shower music
Good Day Sunshine - This song is an embarrassment that would barely qualify for background hooker dismemberment
Love You To - eh
She said, She said - kinda jam to this one
Pet Sounds - LGAFAW is so much better

Marvin or Beach Boys for da win

[madonnas]

	47 The Beach Boys, "I Just Wasn't Made For These Times” AVERAGE:7.43 0: n/a 1: n/a 2: n/a 3: n/a 4: Toysoldier99, madonnas 5: n/a 6: alkralkra, Penk, Bríseis, Lucas32 7: MP2K, supaspaz, Flashing Lights, Rhythm, Adr, Ewan Chaos, Kang., Brando, jqnetto 8: Eizen,Katmari 9: Changes 10: J.YONCÉ, kingfisher, Circinus, FattMatt
“Wouldn’t It Be Nice” / “You Still Believe in Me” / “That’s Not Me” / “Don’t Talk (Put Your Head on my Shoulders)” / “I’m Waiting For the Day” / “Let’s Go Away For Awhile” / “Sloop John B” / “God Only Knows” / “I Know There’s an Answer” / “Here Today” / “I Just Wasn’t Made for These Times” / “Pet Sounds” / “Caroline, No”	Always been my least favorite on this album. I was sad to see it pass many great tracks, but at least it's not that far.

[FattMatt]

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
THE BEST ****ING SONG ON THE RATE *excuse my meltdown*
WHYYYYYYYYYYYYY x1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
I hate you all

[madonnas]

Originally posted by FattMatt

NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
THE BEST ****ING SONG ON THE RATE *excuse my meltdown*
WHYYYYYYYYYYYYY x1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
I hate you all

It's literally the 3rd worst for me

[FattMatt]

Originally posted by madonnas

It's literally the 3rd worst for me

What are the other 2

[madonnas]

	46 The Clash, "Lover's Rock” AVERAGE:7.45 0: n/a 1: 2: 3: 4: Bríseis, Circinus 5: 6: Changes, Penk, Lucas32, Toysoldier99 7: like2throw, J.YONCÉ, Flashing Lights, Katamari, FattMatt 8: Eizen, Adr, kingfisher, jqnetto, madonnas 9: supaspaz, Ewan Chaos, alkralkra, Kang. 10: Rhythm, Brando
“London Calling” / “Brand New Cadillac” / “Jimmy Jazz” / “Hateful” / “Rudie Can’t Fail” / “Spanish Bombs” / “The Right Profile” / “Lost in the Supermarket” / “Clampdown” / “The Guns of Brixton” / “Wrong ‘em Boyo” / “Death or Glory” / “Koka Kola” / “The Card Cheat” / “Lover’s Rock” / “The Four Horsemen” / “Revolution Rock” / “Train in Vain”	This one has a really nice melody for me. I'm not so sure about the production though. It gives a sorta nice street-market feeling but doesn't match the sing-songy melody?

[madonnas]

Originally posted by FattMatt

What are the other 2

wait just 1 worse.... MJ/Paul collab.

[Kingfisher]

i guess i just wasn't made for these times wasn't made for these times

this rate has motivated me to stop dismissing dad-/mom-rock
i downloaded a bob dylan album + that fleetwood mac album and listened to paul mccartney today
simultaneously proud/ashamed

[Penk]

Yeah these 2 were just.. ok.

[FattMatt]

LR should not be even near the masterpiece that is IJWMFTT but whatevs it is still a decent song

[Circinus]

Originally posted by madonnas

I'm lightweight fuming, tbh. I love this song. My favorite song in the rate for sure, and one of my favorites of all time.

[jqnetto]

All those Clash's songs leaving.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Kingfisher

i guess i just wasn't made for these times wasn't made for these times

this rate has motivated me to stop dismissing dad-/mom-rock
i downloaded a bob dylan album + that fleetwood mac album and listened to paul mccartney today
simultaneously proud/ashamed

There's some dad-rock that's actually amazing it's just that it's overrated/lots of it is actually trash.

I hate Bob Dylan's voice though

[FattMatt]

Originally posted by Kingfisher

i guess i just wasn't made for these times wasn't made for these times

this rate has motivated me to stop dismissing dad-/mom-rock
i downloaded a bob dylan album + that fleetwood mac album and listened to paul mccartney today
simultaneously proud/ashamed

Fleetwood Mac and Bob are not mom + dad rock

[Kingfisher]

Originally posted by madonnas

There's some dad-rock that's actually amazing it's just that it's overrated/lots of it is actually trash.

I hate Bob Dylan's voice though

whenever someone mentions bob dylan, i say ''bob dylan is the 'the beatles' of folk and i mean that in a bad way ''
that's how petty i am when it comes to dad-rock

Originally posted by FattMatt

Fleetwood Mac and Bob are not mom + dad rock

ask your mom whether she likes fleetwood mac
if the answer is no, you were adopted