[R`0`K`R]

Guys, please! this video has NO CONCEPT. Far from even being considered even a nominee for Video of the year.

They both look smoking hot. And Beyonce's style did not come through in the video, she looked like an imitation of Shakira.

The song is still crap. The video looks kind of cheap. Where is this Beautiful Liar they are singing about the whole song? They both look really hot, that's about it.

[X-Nicky]

F**k off haters ... this is one of some videos , can turn me on ... hahahaha !!!

Best video 2007 so far !!!

[Bep Rocks!!]

VERY VERY UNDERWHELMING!!..CAN'T BELIEVE JAKE NAVA DIRECTED THIS LAZY DULL EFFORT...SEEMS LIKE GIRLFRIEND AND CANDYMAN HAVE NO COMPETITION FOR BEST FEMALE VID THIS YR..HMM

[LONGWAY2GO.]

i was expecting so much more...

[Pedro]

OMGGGGGGGG

BYE GIRLFRIEND
BYE CANDYMAN
BYE WITH LOVE
BYE AT ALL!

AND HELLO BEAUTIFUL LIAR, IT DESERVES BE THE VIDEO OF THE YEAR
JUST AMAZING <33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 33

[Pedro]

For the hatters _|_

Shut up!

[kalel]

i was expecting more... but i love it

[Nachoz]

youtube link????

[kalel]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-egN0V9i3M

[R`0`K`R]

No one is a hater in here.

I love Shakira, I'm a big fan of hers honestly.

Beyonce is ok, I don't hate her but she gets on my nerves sometimes.

But this video is a disappointment. So you idiots saying we are haters can STFU!

[Anthony K.]

They both look very hot, but that's it, the video has nothing else special. I must say I'm just as disappointed as I am with the song.

[Travis10]

The video is good-OK, but I want to hear a remix for this that'll give the song some needed flavor. (Throw in a Hip-Hop artist? Is T.I, Jay-Z, Lil Wayne, Missy, Luda, etc. doing anything?) The music comes across as kinda bland & boring after 2-3 spins, and there is/was more potential to this song, then just "this" alone. The vocals are fine otherwise. I know these 2 artists can do better.

[►Liyoh◄]

It's great to see them together
And yes, the video isn't great

[Bep Rocks!!]

Originally posted by R0KR of the R0Ks

No one is a hater in here.

I love Shakira, I'm a big fan of hers honestly.

Beyonce is ok, I don't hate her but she gets on my nerves sometimes.

But this video is a disappointment. So you idiots saying we are haters can STFU!

Exactly..I'm so loving u right now for ur comment!!

[Jesus Saves]

I love this video.


Where is UPGRADE U, i want to see it

[Bep Rocks!!]

Originally posted by Pedro-Spears

For the hatters _|_

Shut up!

Please just state ur comment and don't be rude...You can't force anyone to like a video..especially if its not a very good one!!

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by R0KR of the R0Ks

They both look smoking hot. And Beyonce's style did not come through in the video, she looked like an imitation of Shakira.

Have to agree in this, beyonce looks like a wannabe shakira.
Shakira looks hotter also.

Damn, really dissapointed.
This will probably get a female vma just for the names

[**AlphaLovesBee**]

Anyway who cares if this will be the video of the year one thing is sure ppl will request like mad cuz even though it lacks concept its still hot to def what could we expect more than shakira and bee dancin and woirkin their hips together im satisfied with this vid and xtina fans pliz back offf
Shakira + Bee >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3 Xtina (Blonde+Brunette+red)
By the way Green light , get me bodied and kitty kat look fierce

[Da Baddest Bytch!]

Originally posted by **AlphaLovesBee**

Anyway who cares if this will be the video of the year one thing is sure ppl will request like mad cuz even though it lacks concept its still hot to def what could we expect more than shakira and bee dancin and woirkin their hips together im satisfied with this vid and xtina fans pliz back offf
Shakira + Bee >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 3 Xtina (Blonde+Brunette+red)
By the way Green light , get me bodied and kitty kat look fierce

Thank U! EXACTLY! CHRISTINA FANS ARE JUST JEALOUS AND INTIMIDATED BY BEYONCE! this vid/song will be big especially because it has both Beyonce and Shakira in it. A lot of guys will love this video too and this vid/song will prob. pick up a lot of awards..and will also be a big hit!

[mig123]

i love the part when they say "beyonce beyonce Shakira shakira" at the end <333333 classic