[BlackStar_93]

Loved this episode, definitely the grizzliest of S2 so far. I don't suspect Gustavo whatsoever, I feel like he's simply a red-herring placed by the writers to distract from the real killer.

At this point, I'm suspecting the killer to be Keiran. It's a pretty safe option but makes lots of sense. One big giveaway for me is actually from S1, both him and Piper had just moved to Lakewood in E1, Piper moved to "investigate the murders", while Kieran is new to the school, which could mean they came together. I feel like we all missed that, because it's so simple and hidden in plain sight.

Also, I have a theory regarding Hayley and Kieran. I think Kieran and Hayley are a secret item, and Kieran uses Hayley as a pawn to help him orchestrate things, i.e the party at the orphanage, the prank in E1 to scare Audrey etc. Here's the catch though, I don't think Hayley knew Kieran was the actual killer, hence why she seemed shocked when he stabbed her. I think she was just a general bitch and enjoyed bullying people,she didn't know she was actually helping a murderer. I think he killed her for two reasons...
1. She was beginning to slip up and blow his cover (think about the taunting conversation she has with Emma at the party about her "special friend")
2. She was causing too much drama and rubbing it in people's faces (i.e the "freakshow" comment in the hallway at school".
I'm probably wrong but theoretically it kinda makes sense and explains the interaction between Hayley and the killer.

After episode 10 it's pretty obvious that the killers motive is to avenge Piper.

[Vine101]

Hayley was goddamn annoying ugh glad she got killed.

Zoe and Stavo are so sketch.

Also, Stavo is so hot ugh

[Roman Holiday]

Stavo is hot and all and his character is interesting, but I can't help but smh @ Brooke for being so trusting of him. Definition of dick-notized.

[Haus-Of_Mck]

Tavo needs to come for me I'd never Brooke'd u papi

I am really confused about who the killer is

[AccioMiley]

I can't believe I missed it last night ugh

[jgorny]

I can't believe there is only 3 more episodes left. Somebody better die next week. Preferably a major cast member.

[Yndda]

FINALLY GHOSTFACE STOPPED PLAYING and stabbed a bitch! yes! I live! even better, it was that hayley bitch.

and brooke is so… stupid girl's gotta stop putting so much trust in that gustavo dude. he's way too sketch

[lostinparadise]

That was my fave episode of season 2 so far, it was sooooo amazing. I'm now convinced the killer HAS to be Kieran The whole 'Face The Mask' section was FLAW TO THE LESS.

Like, it has to be. If it's any of the new cast I will be low-key disappointed. I want in to be from Season 1 .

The only other alternatives I can think of is Emma, but since she got a text from the Killer this episode, it can't be. And Noah, but according to the trailer for next week...

[Yndda]

Originally posted by Roman Holiday

Stavo is hot and all and his character is interesting, but I can't help but smh @ Brooke for being so trusting of him. Definition of dick-notized.

and Noah is ***-notised by Zoe, with the whole email and all

[Dylangaga]

OMG I'm watching this now!

[Dylangaga]

I'm so confused

[Outlaws]

Was the last episode good? I'm watching it tomorrow!

[Dylangaga]

Is Emma the killer or? I'm so confused

[Dylangaga]

OMFG NOAH!!!!

[Dylangaga]

Akdorifmclakfifjcla OMG face the mask. I'm snatched! But confused!!! Is it daddy Kieran or Gustavo?

[Dylangaga]

Omg that preview!!! Noooooooooooooooooo

[Martyr Of Fame]

Mess. I thought next week was the finale. I was about to post my predictions for the reveal. I didn't know this season had 12 episodes.

I guess, I'll post them anyways:

My Predictions

It's feels so obvious to me that Zoe is one of the killers (if there's multiple). I mean the "Iet's turn off all the lights and electricity while everyone has a mask on!!1" schtick was another giveaway

My first prediction: Eli and Zoe just because Emma, Kieren and Gustavo are too obvious.

My second prediction: Zoe and Kieren. It was my first guess, but I just don't want them to go the Billy route. It feels too cliche. Just like the "Emma's gone crazy/has split personality" theory

[Itskorbitch]

EP 9: They need to stop making Emma seem like the killer, its predictable and annoying.
Daddy Stavo... YUM
Brooks school outfit SLAY.
ETC.

[BlackStar_93]

Just an observation that may narrow down the possible killer(s)...

I just realized something in episode 10... So Emma and Audrey come across Piper's rotting body and it's obviously the killer who put it there. There's a catch though, at the end of S1 everyone is by the lake while the police are searching for Piper's body, and in his monologue Noah says her body was never recovered. The police were presumably called straight to the scene after Audrey shot Piper, that means someone had a really short window of time to retrieve Piper's body from the lake before the police and detectives arrived. My point, all the Lakewood six (Emma, Audrey, Brooke, Jake, Noah and Kieran) are all accounted for during this period, meaning none of them would have had the time or opportunity to retrieve the body without anyone noticing. That means none of them could be the S2 killer! (Even that or there's just a plot hole )

[Roman Holiday]

My predictions are Kieran and Zoe

Kieran for a few reasons:
1) Eli may have been brought in to replace him as Emma's love interest
2) That scene where Haley heckles Emma in the hallway and Kieran tell Hayley to knock it off and they give eachother a stare. It reminded me of the scene in the original film where Billy tells Stu to shut up. I think he was manipulating Haley into thinking he liked her hence her helping him throw the party.
3) I seriously doubt both killers will be newbies. It can't be Brooke or Audrey. Emma seems a bit too obvious at this point. It's either Noah or Kieran.
4) Him and Piper came to Lakewood at the exact same time.
5) I'm pretty sure he killed his parents on purpose.


I think Zoe is his accomplice for some reason, I'm just not sure what.