[fabbriche]

Originally posted by Hi.Ðefinitiøn

This is a horrible list TBH.

Because Beyonce is in it next to Mariah, know that her songwriting ain't no match to Mariah's who could actually write her own songs with few to no co-writers at all?

[fabbriche]

Originally posted by charlecito-05

Sure Mariah Carey has a impressive catalog of hits, but after this

"Whenever I watch TV and see those poor starving kids all over the world, I can't help but cry. I mean I'd love to be skinny like that, but not with all those flies and death and stuff."
- Mariah Carey

I don't know how many of the lyrics she wrote, which according to you are so inspirational, are hers, let alone being truly from her heart if hers.


The whole list is a complete mess, but I'm assuming female POP singer/songwriters according to you are the mainstream artists. If I had to choose a female singer/songwriter that is currently mainstream I would go with P!nk
Amy Lee is my personal favourite, Dolores O'Riordan, Alanis Morissette, Jewel, Sheryl Crow, Nina Persson, Andrea Corr as well aa Hayley Williams and Lacey Mosley are what I would like to see in a poll like this.
I would also like to see how much Lady GaGa can accomplish in the lyrics department. I mean, I certainly know she has talent, but many lyrics she delivered in the Fame were to get exposure, as stupidity sells nowadays. If not Tik Tok wouldn't be song of 2010 according to Billboard.

Don't doubt. Mariah wrote most of her most popular early stuff. She's a legit songwriter. She's won many BMI songwriter's awards. She's never been accused of plagiarism. Most of her songs are drawn from personal experience that I can relate to so I know she wrote them.

[Guy]

Originally posted by charlecito-05

Sure Mariah Carey has a impressive catalog of hits, but after this

"Whenever I watch TV and see those poor starving kids all over the world, I can't help but cry. I mean I'd love to be skinny like that, but not with all those flies and death and stuff."
- Mariah Carey

This has been proven to be a made up quote. Come on, now.

[Drais.]

Originally posted by fabbriche

Because Beyonce is in it next to Mariah, know that her songwriting ain't no match to Mariah's who could actually write her own songs with few to no co-writers at all?

Concerned about Bey AGAIN?

You need to get a life, you've been reported. Hopefully the mods do the forum justice and go ahead and ban your account.

[firstlove]

Originally posted by Hi.Ðefinitiøn

Concerned about Bey AGAIN?

You need to get a life, you've been reported. Hopefully the mods do the forum justice and go ahead and ban your account.

I really didnt see the need for that response he gave you.... at all... Especially when beyonce nor Mariah was mentioned.

[Drais.]

Originally posted by firstlove

I really didnt see the need for that response he gave you.... at all... Especially when beyonce nor Mariah was mentioned.

It'll thing do anything it can to bring up Bey. At this point it's just laughable and pathetic.

[UnusualBoy]

I go with Alicia her songs are epic

[firstlove]

Originally posted by Hi.Ðefinitiøn

It'll thing do anything it can to bring up Bey. At this point it's just laughable and pathetic.

I really hate when people who stan for people who are older in the industry try and tear down the younger acts WITH TALENT. I happen to love Mariah alot as well as Bey but oh well... i guess you cant please everyone... meanwhile..


"Who do you admire out of the new breed of divas?
I don't really follow every new act — they come out constantly. There are so many, it's often hard to keep track, and sometimes they're here today and gone tomorrow. I admire my friends, like Beyonce and Nicki Minaj — people who seem destined to be doing this for a living with longevity"

-Mariah Carey


And im sure you could find something Celine said too. .

[Ace Reject]

Guess who's getting closed? THIS THREAD.