[supertiffany]

"Since U Been Gone"
Released: December 22, 2004
"Behind These Hazel Eyes"
Released: July 5, 2005


ALMOST 7 MONTHS APART!!!

[MJ Boston]

Originally posted by Addicted

Listen up gorls. Tonight the losing song from the rate is gonna be revealed. The official worst song from a Kelly Clarkson album as voted for by ATRL. What do you think it's gonna be? Spill your tea whilst its hot

It's gonna be What's Up Floppy. No doubt in my mind.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Thankful. I think I only gave two zeros.

[MJ Boston]

My guess is that What's Up Floppy, Some Kind of Flop, Thankflop, Not Toflop and Flop (Yeah) will be the first 5 out. Even though I actually like Some Kind Of Flop but I seem to be the only one.

[stoopidjenna]

Originally posted by supertiffany

"Since U Been Gone"
Released: December 22, 2004
"Behind These Hazel Eyes"
Released: July 5, 2005


ALMOST 7 MONTHS APART!!!

I think July was when the Physical CD was released. It was sent for adds probably in April/May.

[ClashAndBurn]

Originally posted by MJ0497

The meltdowns in that Billboard thread are making my day.

Why is this thread more than halfway down page 1? Unacceptable.

I'm bored at work. I need to be entertained.

I just love how people who are bashing the tea are the same ones who use Billboard receipts for their own faves.

Oh well! :banana8:

[jpsketch]

My lowest rate was probably a 5. Can't remember.

[[Bask]]

My lowest rate was 0, even Kelly's angelic voice couldn't help The production destroy the song

[supertiffany]

Addicted is everyone finish? so excited for the rankings

[lpd446]

lol I gave Sober like a 4 because I dont want it to win


And Im calling that Addicted is going to be in the top 3

[KevinKDC]

Thankful

1.The Trouble With Love Is 8
2.Miss Independent 9
3.Low 7
4.Some Kind Of Miracle 8
5. What's Up Lonely 7
6.Just Missed The Train 7
7.Beautiful Disaster 4
8.You Thought Wrong 9
9.Thankful 6
10.Anytime 9
11.A Moment Like This 9
12.Before Your Love 7

Breakaway

1. Breakaway 10
2. Since U Been Gone 10
3. Hazel Eyes 10
4. Because Of You 10
5. Gone 8
6. Addicted 9
7. Where Is Your Heart 7
8. Walk Away 9
9. You Found Me 8
10. I Hate Myself For Losing You 8
11. Hear Me 9
12. Beautiful Disaster (live) 8

My December

1.Never Again 10
2.One Minute 8
3.Hole 7
4.Sober 10
5.Don't Waste Your Time 8
6.Judas 7
7.Haunted 8
8.Be Still 8
9.Maybe 10
10.How I Feel 9
11.Yeah 5
12.Can I Have A Kiss 8
13.Irvine 10
14.Chivas 10
15.Dirty Little Secret 8
16.Not Today (Bonus Track) 8
17.Fading (Bonus Track) 8

All I Ever Wanted

1.My Life Would Suck Without You 10
2.I Do Not Hook Up 9
3.Cry 9
4.Don't Let Me Stop You 8
5.All I Ever Wanted 9
6.Already Gone 10
7.If I Can't Have You 8
8.Save You 8
9.Whyyawannabringmedown 7
10.Long Shot 8
11.Impossible 8
12.Ready 8
13.I Want You 8
14.If No One Will Listen 5
15.Tip Of My Tongue (Bonus Track) 8
16.The Day We Fell Apart(Bonus Track) 9
17.Can We Go Back 7

Stronger

1.Mr. Know It All 9
2.What Doesn't Kill You (Stronger) 10
3.Dark Side 10
4.Honestly 10
5.You Love Me 10
6.Einstein 8
7.Standing In Front Of You 8
8.I Forgive You 9
9.Hello 9
10.The War Is Over 9
11.Let Me Down 10
12.You Can't Win 8
13.Breaking Your Own Heart 7
14.Don't You Wanna Stay 9
15.Alone 9
16.Don't Be A Girl About It 8
17.The Sun Will Rise Feat. Kara DioGuardi 8
18.Why Don't You Try 8

-------------------

Thankful: 7.5
Breakaway: 8.8
My December: 8.4
All I Ever Wanted: 8.2
Stronger: 8.8

So according to my rates:

Breakaway = Stronger > My December > All I Ever Wanted > Thankful

[[Bask]]

Originally posted by Addicted

I'm just waiting on 2 people who said they're doing it right now, so hopefully we get the first update tonight

So everyone: Predictions on the bottom 5 AND predictions on the top 5 please?

Lowest Songs

5 - Beautiful Disaster [Thankful]
4 - Thankful [Thankful]
3 - One Minute [My December]
2 - I Forgive You [Stronger]
1 - Yeah [My December]


Highest Songs

5 - Sober [My December]
4 - Because Of You [Breakaway]
3 - Already Gone [AIEW]
2 - Since U Been Gone [Breakaway]
1 - Behind These Hazel Eyes [Breakaway]

[MJ Boston]

Wow. Looking at those scores it seems I was a rather harsh critic.

I gave one 1, one 1.5, a bunch of 3-5's..

What's Up Floppy a 7? Really?!

[MJ Boston]

Man, I just calculated my averages.. I'm pretty surprised at the results...

1. Stronger - 7.94
2. All I Ever Wanted - 7.50
3. Breakaway - 7.04 The second half of the album TOTALLY brings it down.
4. My December - 7.00
5. Thankful - 5.63

I gave eight 10's: SUBG, BTHE, Sober, MLWSWY, Already Gone, Dark Side, Stronger, DYWS
Lots of 9's for album tracks.. and a few 9.5's..

My lowest were:

What's Up Lonely (1), IHMFLY (1), Einstein (1.5), Not Today (2), Thankful (3.5) and Ready (4.5)



Totally forgot about IHMFLY when I made my bottom 5 prediction. That trash needs to be in there.

[supertiffany]

TOP 5?

any of this.

Sober, SUBG, BTHE, BOY, WDKY, DS, AG close fight though!

[Taigan]

I see What's up Floppy, Some kind of Flop, Flopful and I Flop Myself for Losing You being somewhere near the bottom.

I feel like Addicted could be in the Top 5. Behind These Hazel Eyes and Because of You will DEFINITELY be there too. Irvine could sneak a top 10.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by Addicted

I'm just waiting on 2 people who said they're doing it right now, so hopefully we get the first update tonight

So everyone: Predictions on the bottom 5 AND predictions on the top 5 please?

oh so you'll show all the songs ranking?

can you also provide not much known fact for every song!

I am so demanding, pardon!

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by lpd446

lol I gave Sober like a 4 because I dont want it to win


And Im calling that Addicted is going to be in the top 3

wat...Sober will be in the top 10, stop deluding yourself and Addicted will be top 20.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by Addicted

Haha, facts like what?
I'm gonna put the highest / lowest person for each song

forgot we are in the Kelly thread so all facts about each song is already a common knowledge.

Like Miss Independent is a song written by Xtina (that was not so good example of a not much known trivia. lol), You Thought Wrong was about Justin JK. and Haunted was about a friend?

something like that. LOL!


that would be a lot of work for you!



You're gonna display the persons?

I feel that someone would be bombarded if a good song is given a low score.

sounds fun

[Chivas]

I didn't give a single song a 10. The most any song got was 9.5.