[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Shape

If I were doing a UK singles rate, I wouldn't rate the #1s done by the people who debtued at #1 after The X Factor.

They should at least get a #1 without the Idol boost, y'know?

And like I said, if I include Lady Marmalade then I have to include all featuring women and this rate gets to be too massive

But "A Moment Like This" didn't debut at #1. It climbed to #52 on the strength of radio airplay and then jumped to the top in its third week after the physical single was released.

What does "Lady Marmalade" have to do with featuring artists? All four singers on the track are co-credited.

[jinzo]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

LMAO NICKI'S pathetic.

Though we wouldn't be in this position if Xtina let Woohoo be the #1 worldwide smash it was destined to be...

[Shapes]

Keep on sending these in.

[Shapes]

One more bump, for the hell of it. If I get no rates by the end of tonight, I'll start tallying them up.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Shape

One more bump, for the hell of it. If I get no rates by the end of tonight, I'll start tallying them up.

Shoot, it's due today? The original post says March 10th.

[Shapes]

Well I thought everyone was done.

Just do yours ASAP

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Shape

Well I thought everyone was done.

Just do yours ASAP

I'm about halfway done. I will have it to you in the next two days.

[Shapes]

Sounds good. I'll keep the deadline to the 10th.

[supaspaz]

Finally sent!

I think my top ten would be (in chronological order) "Try Again," "All For You," "Fallin'," "Crazy in Love," "Say It Right," "Umbrella," "Poker Face," "Teenage Dream," "Hold It Against Me" and "Someone Like You." But it will be really competitive; there are so many great songs in this rate.

And also some utter trash. If "Thank God I Found You," "I Kissed a Girl" and "We R Who We R" are not the first three eliminations...

[KitKat]

I'm fairly sure that I've ****ed up the top ten for everyone. Can't wait to see

[eli's_rhythm]

Totally participating tonight or tomorrow. Cool extension.

[Katy V.!]

Sent.

[Shapes]

Originally posted by Katie

I'm fairly sure that I've ****ed up the top ten for everyone. Can't wait to see

You'll be crucified by the stans

[madonnas]

I didn't rate Try Again, should I just give you the rate right now??

[Tsuko]

Originally posted by supaspaz

And also some utter trash. If "Thank God I Found You," "I Kissed a Girl" and "We R Who We R" are not the first three eliminations...

The remix of Thank God I Found You ft. Nas is amazing though (yes guys, pop girls did remixes featuring rappers to get to #1 before Katy Perry did lol), even if the original is a bit boring.

Some people might actually think the remix is the orignial tbh. Here in the UK I heard it on the radio more.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by madonnas

I didn't rate Try Again, should I just give you the rate right now??

Yes. But only if you're giving it a 10.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by madonnas

I didn't rate Try Again, should I just give you the rate right now??

Let me answer for this for Shape!

Yes, send that one to him too. And any votes for Try Again that are less than a seven won't be accepted!

[madonnas]

Originally posted by supaspaz

Yes. But only if you're giving it a 10.

I'm going to give it a 9.5 or a 10 I haven't decided yet.

[Shapes]

I sent a mass message out to people who rated before the change to send me rates for Try Again, and most responded.

Please send me a rating for Try Again if you haven't.

[Shapes]

Today is the LAST DAY to send in your ratings!!

I'll be starting the rate promptly at midnight.