[Deemy]

I wanna do it. Send in ny rates this weekend though.

[Shapes]

Don't stop submitting, I know y'all can rate all of these.

I gave up on this thread once, but I won't again

[umich]

do we have to re-submit if we've done it already?

[Shapes]

Nope, I've still got the PMs.

[DiamondDust]

I'm jumping on this too!

[Auburn]

So excited to see all the overrated stuff like Adele and Mariah dominate.

[supaspaz]

Awesome! I will get on this.

[Beyoncé on Top]

Sent.

I gave 25 10's.

[@michael]

I'm gonna do this. Good thing I have until the 10th.

[Green]

Shape you forgot about some girls:

Try Again - Aaliyah
Lady Marmalade - Christina Aguilera, Lil' Kim, Mya & P!nk
A Moment Like This - Kelly Clarkson
I Believe - Fantasia
Inside Your Heaven - Carrie Underwood

[Shapes]

Originally posted by Green

Shape you forgot about some girls:

Try Again - Aaliyah
Lady Marmalade - Christina Aguilera, Lil' Kim, Mya & P!nk
A Moment Like This - Kelly Clarkson
I Believe - Fantasia
Inside Your Heaven - Carrie Underwood

I didn't include Lady Marmalade because I thought it wouldn't be fair (if featuring artists can count, then there's many more #1s that could be rated, undeserved)

It's peculiar why Aaliyah isn't up there. Whatever too late to change that now.

I didn't include the American Idol winners because their positions are artificial. I don't believe they count for anything.


Keep sending in those rates girls!!!!!!!

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Shape

I didn't include Lady Marmalade because I thought it wouldn't be fair (if featuring artists can count, then there's many more #1s that could be rated, undeserved)

It's peculiar why Aaliyah isn't up there. Whatever too late to change that now.

I didn't include the American Idol winners because their positions are artificial. I don't believe they count for anything.

I think you should at least add in "Lady Marmalade" (why is four lead bitches any different than one?), "Try Again" (do it for Aaliyah!) and "A Moment Like This" (Kelly's #1 was definitely real; the song was also a radio hit).

You can either PM the people who have already voted to send you scores for those additional songs, or just substitute their non-score with the song's eventual overall average.

[jinzo]

Done! Showed a few choice songs the true 1/10 and 2/10 tea.

Also, what's Nicki doing in that picture in the first post? Girl doesn't even have a #1 to her name

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by jinzo

Done! Showed a few choice songs the true 1/10 and 2/10 tea.

Also, what's Nicki doing in that picture in the first post? Girl doesn't even have a #1 to her name

LMAO NICKI'S pathetic.

And Shape, I will be including Try Again in my votes. Ask the same of everyone else please!

[Changes]

Hmm. Lemme do this right quick.

[Allthatisholy]

Sent!

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

And Shape, I will be including Try Again in my votes. Ask the same of everyone else please!

The late, great Princess of R&B is coming for that top ten!

[Shapes]

I refuse to include Lady Marmalade or Moment like This.

I will include Try Again (because Ace will ban me otherwise )

If everyone could send in a rating for Try Again, that'd be wicked.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Shape

I refuse to include Lady Marmalade or Moment like This.

But why? It just seems so arbitrary. (The Fantasia/Carrie snub I understand.)

[Shapes]

Originally posted by supaspaz

But why? It just seems so arbitrary. (The Fantasia/Carrie snub I understand.)

If I were doing a UK singles rate, I wouldn't rate the #1s done by the people who debtued at #1 after The X Factor.

They should at least get a #1 without the Idol boost, y'know?

And like I said, if I include Lady Marmalade then I have to include all featuring women and this rate gets to be too massive

Trust me, I wrestled with all of these for a while.