[LLJungleFever]

1) Kelly Clarkson
2) Carrie Underwood
3) Fantasia Barrino
4) Clay Aiken
5) Ruben Studdard
6) William Hung
7) Diana DeGarmo
8) Bo Bice
9) Kimberley Locke
10) Tamrya Gray
11) Justin Guarini
12) Jasmine Trias
13) Corey Clark
14) Constantine

That list looks about right, right?

[FreakyFlyBry]

I'd rank Bo and Kimberley higher than both William and Diana myself. But the top 5 looks fairly accurate to me.

[kellyc2005]

after the top 5, it should probably be:

6. Josh Gracin
7. Bo Bice
8. Kimberley Locke
9. Tamyra Gray
10. Diana DeGarmo

then the rest....William i would put last

[Fallen Fort Minor]

I would definitely put Bo Bice ahead of William Hung and Diana DeGarmo as Bo has a gold album ,a Top 40 hit, and he's doing well on TRL which can't be said for the other 2.

[Im Not Dead]

I say Clay did better then Fantasia.

[.:Froggert:.]

Carrie will be #1 soon enough

[Mr.Hollywood]

i think clay did better than fantasia? but then again shes like in a movie and has a book and stuff.
i heard that jim verraros' album did ok. and one of his singles went somewhere on the dance chart.
ryan starrs on tour and does tv shows etc.

[Cultie]

William Hung should be #1.

[Kaos]

Originally posted by LLJungleFever

1) Kelly Clarkson
2) Carrie Underwood
3) Fantasia Barrino
4) Clay Aiken
5) Ruben Studdard
6) William Hung
7) Diana DeGarmo
8) Bo Bice
9) Kimberley Locke
10) Tamrya Gray
11) Justin Guarini
12) Jasmine Trias
13) Corey Clark
14) Constantine

That list looks about right, right?

01. kelly clarkson - obviously
02. clay aiken - sold more than any idol with debut album
03. carrie underwood - doing pretty good, will be higher soon
04. fantasia - did okay with album and had a decent success with concerts
05. ruben studdard - did okay with album then what happened?
06. bo bice - actually sold a little bit and his song is actually getting some airplay
07. kimberly locke - didnt sell as well in us but had a semi-hit with 8th world wonder and some sucess overseas
08. jasmine trias - america wise not as lucky but is doing some concerts but is pretty successful in asia
09. diana degarmo - at least her album debuted in BB200 then what happened?
10. william hung - duhhhhhhhhh
11. justina guarini - lolzzzzz
12. tamyra gray - unfortunately what a waste of talent
13. corey clark - just a slight success over constantine lol
14. constantine - hello...

[Brian.]

01 Kelly Clarkson
02 Carrie Underwood
03 Clay Aiken
04 Fantasia
05 Ruben Studdard
06 Bo Bice
07 Josh Gracin
08 Kimberly Locke
09 Diana Degarmo
10 Justin Guarini
Close Calls: Tamyra Gray, William Hung, & Jasmine Trias.

We can soon add Jennifer Hudson to this list. Someone who could have easily been on this list judging by the sound of their unreleased music is Kimberly Caldwell. She just made the wrong career decisions. Alcohol, drugs, TV Guide...

[chibi]

We can soon add Jennifer Hudson to this list. Someone who could have easily been on this list judging by the sound of their unreleased music is Kimberly Caldwell. She just made the wrong career decisions. Alcohol, drugs, TV Guide...

agree 100%

the top 5 of that list looks pretty accurate.

after that i'd probably say:

6) Bo Bice
7) Kimberley Locke
8) Diana Degarmo
9) Jasmine Trias
10) Tamrya Gray
11) William Hung
12) Justin Guarini
13) Corey Clark
14) Constantine

[.Chad.]

Well, we can't forget LaToya.


1) Kelly Clarkson
2) Carrie Underwood
3) Clay Aiken
4) Ruben Studdard
5) Fantasia Barrino
6) Bo Bice
7) Kimberley Locke
8) Diana DeGarmo
9) William Hung
10) Tamrya Gray
11) Justin Guarini
12) LaToya London
13) Jasmine Trias
13) Corey Clark
14) Constantine

I think thats about where it is sales wise.

Originally posted by .:Froggert:.

Carrie will be #1 soon enough

Of course, She's only about 6 million away!

[Kaos]

i dont think carrie will ever be #1 just cause of kelly's overseas success. the only country artist that will always be successful out of the US is shania. carrie is so out of the picture.

[M Z N A]

LFR. Carrie Underwood will always be a WHO outside the U.S., She isn't that good to begin with. Jennifer Hudson better release an album soon.

[Sir. Will]

did anyone say Jennifer Hudson yet... she's going to be in Dreamgirls in December

Durr?